Ok I will post it up here for the heck of it.
The league is a standard 5x5 roto league with keepers. Each year we designate 1 player as a 3 year keeper. Mind you that if you designate a keeper you are stuck with him for 3 years (that is you can't drop or trade him).
My decision is between Arod and Sabathia. The decision was a no brainer about a month ago but recent events including the steroid thing and now the mystery hip injury and making me have second thoughts. An elite 5 tool player is always going to have more value over even the best pitchers but with the serious unknowns stemming from the injury I have become very torn (heard the possibility of a Bo Jackson type injury thrown around).