Our mission

Actual live rock at SWA

JVU said:
Curing rock means different things to different people. I would think with wet/damp rock you’d put it in a bucket with saltwater, flow, and a heater for maybe 1-2 weeks to let dead stuff decompose (and let living stuff stay living). Not the more intensive curing process that includes actively killing everything and then letting it reseed for many weeks or months that some people mean by curing.
Click to expand...

This is what I was referring to. Not cooking rock.
 
JVU said:
Curing rock means different things to different people. I would think with wet/damp rock you’d put it in a bucket with saltwater, flow, and a heater for maybe 1-2 weeks to let dead stuff decompose (and let living stuff stay living). Not the more intensive curing process that includes actively killing everything and then letting it reseed for many weeks or months that some people mean by curing.

Though if it’s going into a mature larger tank probably just putting it in is fine since there’s already an active microbiome to process the decomposition.
Click to expand...

Short cures were still weeks long. 60 lb. Boxes of Totoka & Vanuatu rock cost the same as a 5lb order of what's currently available. It always came in damp and smelling like hot butt, but had all sorts of crap on it. Waiting for all of it to die off took forever. My garage would smell like divorce was in the air if I didn't get it in the tank soon.

@gimmito where you at Jim?! If you still got that rock I sold you, you could make a killin!!!! Lol
 
Rocks came today. Shipping took longer than usual to get started, but this is different from dry goods.

Rocks were moist, but not wet. I got 3 big pieces and a couple little ones.

No bad smell, so hopefully doing what it needs to do.

1000000570.jpg
1000000571.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 1000000569.jpg
    1000000569.jpg
    53.8 KB · Views: 21
Last edited:
iani said:
What are your initial thoughts?
Click to expand...
I like that they use a heat pack, and the bag is double layer and water tight. Seems like they let the rocks drip dry for a bit to minimize shipping weight prior to packaging. The shape of the rocks is cool, almost like a large pukani. Any specific questions?
 
H2OPlayar said:
I like that they use a heat pack, and the bag is double layer and water tight. Seems like they let the rocks drip dry for a bit to minimize shipping weight prior to packaging. The shape of the rocks is cool, almost like a large pukani. Any specific questions?
Click to expand...
Does it look like there is a lot of "life" on the rock? Or is it pretty bare?
 
iani said:
Does it look like there is a lot of "life" on the rock? Or is it pretty bare?
Click to expand...
Pretty bare, looks like you are only really getting the bacterial input. All 3 big rocks looked like the one I took the picture of in that they look clean and free from coralline or other algae, and I didn't see any critters.
 
I’d be livid if I paid $20/lb and received that lol There’s a guy on R2R selling some of the nicest wild Australia live rock I’ve seen around lately… at least based on the pics and the countless people who have bought from him on that forum… but $25/lb + steep shipping I believe. Apparently he will video chat so you can pick out your rock specifically.
 
B the Nano Reefer said:
I’d be livid if I paid $20/lb and received that lol There’s a guy on R2R selling some of the nicest wild Australia live rock I’ve seen around lately… at least based on the pics and the countless people who have bought from him on that forum… but $25/lb + steep shipping I believe. Apparently he will video chat so you can pick out your rock specifically.
Click to expand...

Submerged in water shipping?
 
Alexander1312 said:
Submerged in water shipping?
Click to expand...
With shipping costs lately I doubt it's shipped submerged in water. Most places will just place wet paper towels inside with the rock. When I brought in a shipment of Aussie live rock there wasn't much life on it but it was wet.
 
Arvin R said:
With shipping costs lately I doubt it's shipped submerged in water. Most places will just place wet paper towels inside with the rock. When I brought in a shipment of Aussie live rock there wasn't much life on it but it was wet.
Click to expand...
Yep, and that’s a pass for me then. KP Aquatics ships them submerged and if I am desperate I go to Tampa Bay. These wet newspaper practices are not appealing to me.
 
I think it really depends on what ones goal is when purchasing.

The pics on SWA are pretty transparent as to how this rock looks. Nothing showstopping about it, but if the goal is to diversify one's biome, I do find it of value. I think it's great for the hobby, as most of our options have been limited to "premium aquacultured".

Yea, it's not packed in water....but neither was any of that other rock we used 25 years ago packed in it as well..didn't have enough crabs or worms? Just buy em separately..

Hell, there's aquascapes that are selling for 10 times the cost of this and are bone dry. BUT, they're nice to look at..

Again, all comes down to intended goals.

In a year, after its all encrusted with stuff, is there really someone that can tell the difference between them? Maybe back then, yes...distinctive shapes, coral patterns, and porosity were easy tells...nowadays, everything looks like maricultured marcorocks.

The pieces I got are decently shaped, base rock vibes, and are not permanent for my own set up..once they have spread their bacterial cooties to the rest of my rock, I would consider their job done and find someone who can use them from there. I was fortunate to have some macro life in my order...some I kept, others that were questionable were discarded. But I would imagine it's the same way with purchasing from any other supplier.
20250225_170619.jpg
20250225_170609.jpg
20250225_170658.jpg
20250225_170604.jpg
20250225_170558.jpg
 
B the Nano Reefer said:
Not sure. Haven’t inquired/looked into in much other than seeing pictures, videos and reading rave reviews on a a couple very lengthy threads on R2R. Looks like the site is, Premium Australian Live Rock

Here’s a link to one of his threads on R2R R2R Forum Link
Click to expand...
Ok, bit the bullet for everyone and ordering this one too for science sake. They are out of stock on the premium, but told me to order the decorative for 30/lb. The video he sent has lots of life on the rocks, so I am hopeful. I'll keep everyone updated on this other shipment as well.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top