Too much signal is bad as well, that's why I wonder about your amplifier. knowing the specific channel/s where the digital service/s travels through, will tell a tech if the trouble is at the modem/box, splitter, ground block or tap.
I'm out of touch with today's CATV services; wish I could help you a bit. I have a friend, supervisor at Comcast and I asked him about the signal meters since I wanted to sell mine; he told me they are of seldom use but only since signal is really good all over the area and technicians use an "app" to activate services; still, a meter is a great tool when troubleshooting.