gimmito said:Thales said:gimmito said:BAYMAC said:joining in late, but wanted to comment on an old inaccurate post:
gimmito said:If the tank was glass and treated with copper then you can't put inverts in there (copper leaches from the silicone).
Urban legend, myth. It cannot leach enough to effect anything, or even be detectable. Not only did I ask this to RHF and a few others, I tested it with an old 20h from a LFS I worked at that always ran copper.
Funny...Dr.Timothy Miller Morgan at the Hatfield Marine Science Research Institute recommends not using tanks that have been treated with copper for inverts also. Sorry if I don't take your advice as gospel.![]()
But why take Timothy Miller Morgan's advice as gospel? I could curl your hair with advice from
researchers that is way off base. Also saying he recommends that you not use copper treated tanks for inverts is different from saying that the copper gets adsorbed by the tank or seals and then is re released, that you can't put inverts in such a tank, and is often just a way of saying 'not sure about this, but why not play it safe'.
We talk about this a lot in ceph circles, and I can't find anyone that can supply any evidence that it is actually a problem. And, when the claims of copper in such a tank killing inverts get examined, there are almost always plenty of other things that have happened that explain the deaths.
While I do respect Dr. Miller Morgan, I do not take any one person's advice as gospel (in the hobby). My thought on the subject is why take the chance on killing a animal when a new QT is cheap ?
Gotcha, but that is very different from what you originally wrote. The first thing you wrote was presented as 'fact', the second was a defense of the first (and an appeal to authority), and the third is very different and much more accurate and reasonable.
You know its kind of my thing to look for accuracy and in communication and thinking and to try to kill old reefers tales in their tracks, so sorry if this seems pedantic and I hope it doesn't come across as dicky.
if we all strive to be reasonable and accurate we will move the hobby forward more quickly and stop the spread of inaccurate old reefers tales to cost people money in an already expensive hobby and lives of animals.