Welcome to BAR - the Bay Area's premier saltwater hobbyists hub!

Anna & Pablo’s RSR P650

Kessil
Guest
Joined
Aug 8, 2016
Messages
1,611
I’ve been a bad reefer. The MEN distracted me from a slow crash and then I went on vacation (after adding a bunch of wrasses). A lot of coral is dead or dying including some softies. My entire green birds nest colony is dead. The only silver lining is that the fish are all happy.

I don’t know the cause, but I will start with water changes and fixing the issues I know about - like depleted DI resin. I’m going to pivot away from SPS once things are healthy again and simplify my tank.
Sounds like about the state I got to :(
Sorry to hear about your losses
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
I just tested for phosphate and I measured 1 ppm. This could be the cause of my massive die off, or part of the result. I have no algae but I do have some Cyano. Nitrates are 25 ppm.

Has anyone ever hit such high phosphate? Is it deadly? Is GFO my best course of action? I’ve done 4 water changes in a week - before this measurement.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2021
Messages
3,459
I have hit .5, while I know Thales has hit 1 like you. The corals seem to be able to withstand it for a while, but I believe it inhibits new growth. Lanthanum chloride dripped in a fine sock or gfo are the common solutions. I use a gfo reactor that I run 6 hours a day and change the media on every month.
 
Last edited:
Past President
Joined
Mar 26, 2010
Messages
18,870
I have seen it that high in thriving tanks. The overall number would worry me some, especially if you’re having problems with coral health or algae. I think if it goes up that high slowly many corals can handle it. Make sure you don’t bring it down to fast. I’d go with gfo in a reactor. Start w a small amount changed weekly or every other week and build up if needed.
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
The 22g frag tank has been fully converted to a water change vessel.

I started out with the XP Aqua Flood Guardian to fill it with RODI.

I then added a Fluval E100 heater. I like this one because it has an LCD display that shows the temp and changes color from blue to green to red.

Next, was a Neptune WAV - I have several spares and I love the single cable to the EB832.

A spare Neptune PMUP is used to drain the old water. I plumbed it with 3/8” tubing to a drain. It’s also a single cable to the EB832 and has run-dry protection.

Topped it all off with a snazzy ABS lid from Tap Plastics (really great people)

So, all I do is this:
Turn off the return pump to the tank.
Turn on the PMUP to drain the old water.
Turn on the Flood Guardian to fill it with RODI.
Once full, turn on the WAV and the heater to get it to temp.
Throw in the salt.
Let it mix, test salinity and then turn the return pump on - new water flows into the sump.
Turn everything else off.

B5541D38-15E8-42CE-8060-06496AF47B5B.jpeg
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
Looks like my wrasses have taken care of the MEN. None are visible and this devastated monti cap has white growth edges.

F26F86FF-341E-4555-925B-07BBF8275BFE.jpeg
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
The water change system failed me. I neglected to put a siphon break on the drain line and it happened, lost all its water. Fortunately I was nearby and heard unusual water sounds. Caught it just in time.

I added a siphon break and a valve on the drain line.
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
My ICP results came in today.

A9EC8BF9-36C5-49F1-9C76-D9CB2D5F9364.jpeg


I don’t know what to make of it but Lithium is very high. Where could it come from? Should I be concerned about the others? Bromine and Boron? I’ve had a lot of coral death in the past few months
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
After some googling, it seems IO Reef Crystals is the source and it’s not harmful. The others don’t seem to be an issue - so the ICP results don’t explain my tank’s issues
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
This monti barely survived the MEN and is making an incredible comeback.

FB69A0E6-8F2D-4207-92A4-D1863402E63C.jpeg
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
Do you think they are gone?
I have not seen any - or any evidence of their destruction. I’d like to think my wrasses are keeping them in check.
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
Today, the sun was shining through the tank, casting a mesmerizing shadow.


The tank turned 2 yrs old this week!
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
8,331
Today, the sun was shining through the tank, casting a mesmerizing shadow.


The tank turned 2 yrs old this week!
yet a truly unnatural perspective of the sun for the fish!

congrats on the anniversary
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
Having a bit of an emergency, not sure what to do. Skimmer overflowed and fish are not happy. How can I get rid of this foam?

9705F2C0-330D-4EFB-8F3B-00411C417E8A.jpeg
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2016
Messages
3,943
Having a bit of an emergency, not sure what to do. Skimmer overflowed and fish are not happy. How can I get rid of this foam?

View attachment 38365

I’d probably try to scoop it out with a big spoon, ladle, pan, container or even a plastic bag.

Did you add something that made it bubble city?
 
Webmaster
BOD
Joined
Oct 8, 2019
Messages
3,161
Nothing added. I have neglected my tank lately
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2021
Messages
3,459
Having a bit of an emergency, not sure what to do. Skimmer overflowed and fish are not happy. How can I get rid of this foam?

View attachment 38365
I do this all the time, put a tube in the skimmer to syphon the goop out into a bucket, and then let the skimmer run for a few hours like that, it will fill up and drain until things are back to normal. Replace the lost volume with fresh salt water. You can adjust the skimmer to run a little wetter while you do this, and then after a few hours, pull it back to normal.
 
Top