tribbitt
Supporting Member
That’s a nice echinata
Last edited:
Complete Bonus/Ultra Coral List - 2024 (REVISED AS OF 11/14/24)
- Thread starter IOnceWasLegend
- Start date
Yodas seem like a reasonable lookalike; unfortunately, those would not qualify as bonus or ultra.
Alexander1312
Supporting Member
Thank you. I thought I saw them under the bonus zoa list. Maybe I misunderstood.
They were on the list, but going through and looking at current prices/availability/commonality, they've been removed. Some corals on the list are on the list due to inertia, and I haven't had the time or ability to go through and re-check every single one unless it's called to my attention.
Alexander1312
Supporting Member
Understood. Thanks for clarifying.
tribbitt
Supporting Member
In the main post you said:
This is a little confusing. Caulerpa is the only disallowed macroalgae? Or, what is the exception macro that is allowed (and why are almost all disallowed)?
If Caulerpa spp. is the only disallowed type of macro, here's a question: I have a piece of blue hypnea, which is priced decently high and grows pretty slow, can I bring that as a bonus? TSA has priced it at $50 for a 1" ball, which is sort of in line with certain other corals. I also have not seen this at all in this club, and it should probably be in the hands of a reefer who is better at macroalgae than I.
topshelfaquatics.com
This is a little confusing. Caulerpa is the only disallowed macroalgae? Or, what is the exception macro that is allowed (and why are almost all disallowed)?
If Caulerpa spp. is the only disallowed type of macro, here's a question: I have a piece of blue hypnea, which is priced decently high and grows pretty slow, can I bring that as a bonus? TSA has priced it at $50 for a 1" ball, which is sort of in line with certain other corals. I also have not seen this at all in this club, and it should probably be in the hands of a reefer who is better at macroalgae than I.
Blue Hypnea Macroalgae
Blue Hypnea is a blue, slow growing macroalgae. You will receive a 1″ – 1.5″ ball of Blue Hypnea. It prefers higher Light and Flow.
topshelfaquatics.com
tribbitt
Supporting Member
Oh, and @IOnceWasLegend I have a few (I think) tank spawned splatter hammers. One of them might go to the swap. Is there a size requirement? Fully opened, it's a quarter in size. Is there a premium on spawned corals (bumped up 1 tier or something) or is it bonus?
TSA prices are always inflated. I've seen the hypnea for $10 or less it's pretty common. https://cultivatedreef.com/product/blue-hypnea/ so I don't think it's an appropriate item to include as a frag.In the main post you said:
This is a little confusing. Caulerpa is the only disallowed macroalgae? Or, what is the exception macro that is allowed (and why are almost all disallowed)?
If Caulerpa spp. is the only disallowed type of macro, here's a question: I have a piece of blue hypnea, which is priced decently high and grows pretty slow, can I bring that as a bonus? TSA has priced it at $50 for a 1" ball, which is sort of in line with certain other corals. I also have not seen this at all in this club, and it should probably be in the hands of a reefer who is better at macroalgae than I.
Blue Hypnea Macroalgae
Blue Hypnea is a blue, slow growing macroalgae. You will receive a 1″ – 1.5″ ball of Blue Hypnea. It prefers higher Light and Flow.
The hammer you have would be considered a regular coral.
I thought it was evident given that possession of caulerpa is a crime. To clarify (and I've updated this in the post), macroalgae and sponges are not valid frags. They are valid to be given away as freebies, with the exception of caulerpa, since that will get you hit with a hefty fine in CA.In the main post you said:
This is a little confusing. Caulerpa is the only disallowed macroalgae? Or, what is the exception macro that is allowed (and why are almost all disallowed)?
If Caulerpa spp. is the only disallowed type of macro, here's a question: I have a piece of blue hypnea, which is priced decently high and grows pretty slow, can I bring that as a bonus? TSA has priced it at $50 for a 1" ball, which is sort of in line with certain other corals. I also have not seen this at all in this club, and it should probably be in the hands of a reefer who is better at macroalgae than I.
Blue Hypnea Macroalgae
Blue Hypnea is a blue, slow growing macroalgae. You will receive a 1″ – 1.5″ ball of Blue Hypnea. It prefers higher Light and Flow.
While aquacultured vs maricultured corals are something to strive for, we have no way of verifying whether this is the case or not, and it adds another layer of complexity on what's already a fairly busy process getting the bonus and ultra coral processed. So no, unfortunately that does not bump it up another tier. The size requirement is a single polyp/head of hammer; and again - not an exact science, the general criteria is, "Would I be able to recognize what I'm getting, and would I be happy receiving this as a frag?"
tribbitt
Supporting Member
I see about the hypnea - I'll still bring it as a freebie for someone who can appreciate it more.
Splatter hammer is on the Bonus list? Is it regular because of size?
tribbitt
Supporting Member
Yes. I would never want to own caulerpa, even outside of it being illegal, especially with the news and reports of it spreading everywhere, including in our own bay.
And I get the nightmare of trying to make sure everyone who claims they've got spawned coral actually has spawned coral.
Splatter hammer would be a bonus coral.
I'm heading to bed, so—unfortunately—there is now a cutoff on any further questions/additions for the bonus and ultra list for the 6/1 swap.
Reiterating, especially given tomorrow is going to be even busier tomorrow because we have 78 people swapping (with 118 people RSVPd), that we will not consider bonus/ultra corals tomorrow at check-in that are not on the list. It will be hectic and crazy and, unfortunately, we will not have time to do so.
Reiterating, especially given tomorrow is going to be even busier tomorrow because we have 78 people swapping (with 118 people RSVPd), that we will not consider bonus/ultra corals tomorrow at check-in that are not on the list. It will be hectic and crazy and, unfortunately, we will not have time to do so.
Apologies for the late notice---I may not get an answer before the swap: Does Vivid's Kaleidoscope Goni count for the bonus list? Here is a picture from the vendor. It looks much better in person. Looks nicer than my Amazeballs Goni albeit that specimen is still acclimating to my tank.
Picture: https://vividaquariums.com/products/kaleidoscope-goniopora-coral?variant=40665274417237
Picture: https://vividaquariums.com/products/kaleidoscope-goniopora-coral?variant=40665274417237
MarcosDelgado0
Supporting Member
Looks like all Goni are bonus
Attachments
All goni’s qualify as at least bonus. The more expensive named ones can be ultra. I don’t think the pic associated with that link is correct, that looks like their purple Goni, and I’m assuming something named Kaleidoscope will have more than one solid color. If it’s a brighter multicolored named Goni it would normally quality as ultra, but Josh made the cutoff for new asks before your post.
@FooFtr did you bring this to the swap?
We are working on something. Last time the bonus and ultra rounds were chaos.