With the settings you mentioned (which are the default settings), it will turn on heating at 74F or lower then turn that off at 77F, and will turn on cooling at 80F or higher, and turn that off at 77F.
So with the behavior you described, it probably was 80F or higher at some point, and the cooling is staying on until it gets to 77F or lower. If you unplug/replug it it will reset and turn off the cooling.
Those settings are bit of a large temp swing, keeping temp between 74F-80F. I recommend decreasing the HD and CD values, probably to their lowest value of 1. If you kept the TS at 77F, then this would turn on heating at 76F or lower (to be turned off at 77F or higher), and turn on cooling at 78F or higher (to be turned off at 77F or lower). So in other words will keep your tank between 76F and 78F if you have both heating and cooling devices plugged in.
View attachment 36725