Welcome to BAR - the Bay Area's premier saltwater hobbyists hub!

Torch dropped bunch of polyps - can this reattach?

Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,629
Realized a bit too late some brutal coral warfare between some hammers and torches and one of the torches dropped a bunch of polyps.

Should I put this in a mushroom box and let it reattach to a frag plug? Or is this not worth it or likely to survive?

IMG_8341.webp
IMG_8340.webp
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2023
Messages
503
Are you sure it’s coral warfare? It might be worth it to isolate and Monitor for BJD. Better safe than sorry. Also I see some flat worms so it might also be causing that. Dip?
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,629
Are you sure it’s coral warfare? It might be worth it to isolate and Monitor for BJD. Better safe than sorry. Also I see some flat worms so it might also be causing that. Dip?
Yes, the hammer next to it extended their tentactles threefold+ for the past 3 days or more to just reach this head and the one next to it, the others are fine and have more flatworms/they all have for 6 months or so already. I have not found a good solution for it yet, but the population does not grow.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,818
nothing to loose leaving the baled out head in a mushroom cage they look like cool baby bubble tips.. Ive had a few in the past do the same thing but unfortunately they only lasted about a month in half. Other reefers have had success growing new skeleton base.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
8,625
I see flatworms
Remove from tank a dip
FW dip will cause them to drop off
I see at least 4….
That means there are many more!
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,629
I see flatworms
Remove from tank a dip
FW dip will cause them to drop off
I see at least 4….
That means there are many more!
There are - but again, I do not know how to eradicate them. All LPS have them. When I went down the flatworm eradication rabbit hole, it looked like it was better to manage them vs adding stuff int the tank. All LPS have ben dipped multiple times, but they also sit on some mushrooms etc.

My dragonette gets bigger and bigger, and the melanurus wrasse might eat them too. But not enough fish power to get rid of all of them.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
8,625
There are - but again, I do not know how to eradicate them. All LPS have them. When I went down the flatworm eradication rabbit hole, it looked like it was better to manage them vs adding stuff int the tank. All LPS have ben dipped multiple times, but they also sit on some mushrooms etc.

My dragonette gets bigger and bigger, and the melanurus wrasse might eat them too. But not enough fish power to get rid of all of them.
herpes...
if at all possible
in a brute can, maybe 22gal or better 32 gal full freshwater (drinking level quality, not purified)
dip the entire rock
do it like every few days for a couple weeks will definitely reduce the population
submerge n shake then return to tank
even better to have 2 fw dip cans and then a sw rinse then return to tank
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,629
herpes...
if at all possible
in a brute can, maybe 22gal or better 32 gal full freshwater (drinking level quality, not purified)
dip the entire rock
do it like every few days for a couple weeks will definitely reduce the population
submerge n shake then return to tank
even better to have 2 fw dip cans and then a sw rinse then return to tank
All of my rocks are covered in coral. So this will not work, unfortunately.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2023
Messages
483
There are - but again, I do not know how to eradicate them. All LPS have them. When I went down the flatworm eradication rabbit hole, it looked like it was better to manage them vs adding stuff int the tank. All LPS have ben dipped multiple times, but they also sit on some mushrooms etc.

My dragonette gets bigger and bigger, and the melanurus wrasse might eat them too. But not enough fish power to get rid of all of them.
What are you using to dip? Those kind of flatworms will disintegrate via a KCl dip. For all euphilia I add to my tank I use one of those electric dental tartar removers and run on every hard surface. Any pest eggs get removed.

 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,629
What are you using to dip? Those kind of flatworms will disintegrate via a KCl dip. For all euphilia I add to my tank I use one of those electric dental tartar removers and run on every hard surface. Any pest eggs get removed.

Unfortunately, this is a legacy issue from a time when I was not very familiar with proper dipping and inspection protocols. I dare to say it would not happen anymore these days.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,818
Have you ever attempted flat worm exit? It does help knock down the planaria population with three to four repeat treatments. Its will affect your pods, bristles worms, snails , sensitive fish so its a process. I did remove several fish and cucs during the dosing. I put a few planaria in a cup then started adding drops to figure out the strength needed to kill them. The dosing strength on the box had zero effect on the planaria not sure why but gave the wrasses a definite jump eradicating them. There are reports of FWE nuking tanks especially expired boxes but also successful journals. This was a couple years back honestly not sure I’d use fwe again just double or triple down on wrasses / springers but haven’t seen one flatworm in over a year so far which were the harmless ones by the way just unsightly buggers.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
8,625
In freshwater?

The only time I tried to dip a toadstool in RODI a few months ago (for 1-2 minutes only) almost killed it. Is freshwater different, and do you think this will not impact the acros on the rock?
Yes…
Dip, shake, return
No need to let it sit
The flatworms will flee and melt
It’s only in FW for seconds
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2022
Messages
610
Like @PjFish said, I had good luck with 3x treatments of Flatworm exit. I also had to use a higher than recommended dose to eradicate them. I didn't notice any side effects. I think the main concern is toxins released by dying flatworms. I made sure to remove as many as I could and did a large water change between treatments.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,818
I’ve dipped, shaken,brushed football sized rocks covered in nems, zoas and leathers fairly hardy stuff in temp matching distilled or rodi water to chicken to attempt tap water lol.. But definitely use a square bin alot easier with bigger rocks. Black bins hard to see anything that falls off so I use the clear or different colored ones. Or white buckets with small rocks. After quick dip and shake in temp matching rodi I place in saltwater bin for a few minutes then repeat another fast dip in shake again in rodi then back in saltwater bin shaking more. but I have pumps in both bins water is fairly turbulent. Also did this once a week for several weeks before I treated with Flatworm exit.. Logic was to knock down populations ahead of treatment so would lessen the toxicity when they all died off at once. Not sure how other corals handle freshwater dip.. Funny at the older coral farmers market was common to see people in the restrooms rinsing off their frags in the sinks which left some serious slime residues
 
Top