Welcome to BAR - the Bay Area's premier saltwater hobbyists hub!

7.5 Gallon Bookshelf Nano

Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2023
Messages
134
When you dose the ESV nitrate, is the solution getting cold? That would likely indicate it is calcium nitrate since it's endothermic.

Have you tried ammonium bicarbonate yet?
It's room temperature. I've only tried the ESV stuff. It took a while to dial in the right dosage, but it has raised the nitrates on my tests so it seems to be doing its job. Five drops per day directly into the tank has keep the nitrates steady around 20 ppm for several months now. Does ammonium bicarbonate raise ammonium?
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2024
Messages
2,599
Running activated carbon may help reduce risk of coral disease by lowering dissolved organic carbon. Increased DOC is linked with increased copiotrophic bacterial growth. If something starts dying, I take it out immediately for the same reason. Virulent bacteria won't stay on just that coral and may increase risk of coral disease elsewhere

It seems like you run higher amounts of light. Corals produce harmful byproducts during photosynthesis, ROS. Those need to leave the coral, so things like trace elements (mechanisms to move it out) and flow (making the boundary layer thinner) can help.

In a tank this small I recommend using sand too. My 10gallon is doing meh because I don’t have sand in it too
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2024
Messages
825
Running activated carbon may help reduce risk of coral disease by lowering dissolved organic carbon. Increased DOC is linked with increased copiotrophic bacterial growth. If something starts dying, I take it out immediately for the same reason. Virulent bacteria won't stay on just that coral and may increase risk of coral disease elsewhere

It seems like you run higher amounts of light. Corals produce harmful byproducts during photosynthesis, ROS. Those need to leave the coral, so things like trace elements (mechanisms to move it out) and flow (making the boundary layer thinner) can help.

In a tank this small I recommend using sand too. My 10gallon is doing meh because I don’t have sand in it too

I dont see a 10g build thread i wanna see what that one looks like is it as colorful as the 20g
 
Vice President
BOD
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
5,463
It's room temperature. I've only tried the ESV stuff. It took a while to dial in the right dosage, but it has raised the nitrates on my tests so it seems to be doing its job. Five drops per day directly into the tank has keep the nitrates steady around 20 ppm for several months now. Does ammonium bicarbonate raise ammonium?
Ah ok so it isn't a powder. If it was a powder you mix into a solution, that would be the dead giveaway with it getting cold.

The idea behind using ammonium vs. nitrate is that it's more energy efficient for bacteria and corals to use it since they don't need to convert it as far.

 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2023
Messages
134
Running activated carbon may help reduce risk of coral disease by lowering dissolved organic carbon. Increased DOC is linked with increased copiotrophic bacterial growth. If something starts dying, I take it out immediately for the same reason. Virulent bacteria won't stay on just that coral and may increase risk of coral disease elsewhere
This seems correct to me. I do anecdotally feel like when one is unhappy it affects the balance in the system. I could see there being a real benefit to being stricter in a smaller tank with pulling things that aren't doing well. It's a tough line drawing question. You don't want to throw things out that can be saved. But you should also be real - erring on the side of aggressive - about those that probably aren't going to come back.

I briefly ran chemipure, but I don't have a good place to put it. I put it in the back of the tank (where the powerhead is now) but it quickly became a detritus trap, so I removed it. I mostly rely on my oversized skimmer to take care of dissolved organics. The Tunze 9004 is rated by Germans for up to 60 gallons and 20 gal for a heavy bio load. The cup does seem to fill quicker when there's something struggling.

It seems like you run higher amounts of light. Corals produce harmful byproducts during photosynthesis, ROS. Those need to leave the coral, so things like trace elements (mechanisms to move it out) and flow (making the boundary layer thinner) can help.
I definitely do run my light higher. Are you suggesting turning it down? I'm open to the idea that I'm overdoing it. My theory is to give the corals as much light energy as they can stand. Plus the long photo period is just nice. The tank is mostly on while I'm awake.

About dosing trace elements, I thought I was good with water changes and ESV, but maybe I'm not understanding that right. Are you suggesting some sort of dosing?

It seems like it's really hard to get good flow. My current setup with a powerhead pointed up straight up has very strong flow in some areas, but it's quite turgid in others. I'm also finding it really hard to get that prized random flow with just one pump. Alternating the power intensity helps, but the truth is it primarily pushes in one direction. I actually have an mp10 coming soon that I'm going to experiment with. I know the new tank will have mp10s, so I thought I'd play around with this one on the current tank.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2024
Messages
2,599
I definitely do run my light higher. Are you suggesting turning it down? I'm open to the idea that I'm overdoing it. My theory is to give the corals as much light energy as they can stand. Plus the long photo period is just nice. The tank is mostly on while I'm awake. Are you suggesting some sort of dosing?
I personally run really high light on my tank too, it just sort of looked like the monti was dying back on the top where it's really close to the light. It could be another irritant, but just something to be aware of.

Trace elements are a whole ordeal with a ton of opinions, so it's completely up to you if and how you want to chase that

It seems like it's really hard to get good flow.
Yeah, that's just a small tank thing lol. The flow is never quite how you want it

I dont see a 10g build thread i wanna see what that one looks like is it as colorful as the 20g
I don't want to derail the thread but it's my budget build
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,610
Unless I misread but is the issue not rather running a relatively high alk with ultra low nutrients, which stresses the corals. Alk at these low nutrients should be more in the lower 7 range. And not sure how you test, but my Hanna understates dkh readings. Also, Hanna in the ultra-low phosphate range might not be accurate and actually could be lower or 0 even if it provides a number.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2023
Messages
134
it just sort of looked like the monti was dying back on the top where it's really close to the light.
Definitely possible it was the light. I was confused by that one because it grew aggressively for six months, wobbled a couple times and came back, and then began a slow decline that I couldn't reverse.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2023
Messages
134
Unless I misread but is the issue not rather running a relatively high alk with ultra low nutrients, which stresses the corals. Alk at these low nutrients should be more in the lower 7 range. And not sure how you test, but my Hanna understates dkh readings. Also, Hanna in the ultra-low phosphate range might not be accurate and actually could be lower or 0 even if it provides a number.
I hadn't heard that, but I will try that. I also like the idea of alk in the lower 7 range because then if I go out of town and the manual dosing doesn't get done, the alk is only dropping from 7 to 5 which isn't a big swing.

Yes, I test with Hanna checkers. My Hanna ultra-low phosphate is 0.00 probably two thirds of the time. If it does have a number, it's usually less than 0.05. That seems too low to me. Even when the ESV calcium nitrate raised the nitrates, the phosphates stayed stuck at zero. I could dose something. Mad scientist is not really my style of aquarium keeping, but I'm willing to experiment. I'm already dosing three different potion bottles.
 
DBTC Coordinator
BOD
Joined
Jun 27, 2022
Messages
2,343
This seems correct to me. I do anecdotally feel like when one is unhappy it affects the balance in the system. I could see there being a real benefit to being stricter in a smaller tank with pulling things that aren't doing well. It's a tough line drawing question. You don't want to throw things out that can be saved. But you should also be real - erring on the side of aggressive - about those that probably aren't going to come back.

I briefly ran chemipure, but I don't have a good place to put it. I put it in the back of the tank (where the powerhead is now) but it quickly became a detritus trap, so I removed it. I mostly rely on my oversized skimmer to take care of dissolved organics. The Tunze 9004 is rated by Germans for up to 60 gallons and 20 gal for a heavy bio load. The cup does seem to fill quicker when there's something struggling.


I definitely do run my light higher. Are you suggesting turning it down? I'm open to the idea that I'm overdoing it. My theory is to give the corals as much light energy as they can stand. Plus the long photo period is just nice. The tank is mostly on while I'm awake.

About dosing trace elements, I thought I was good with water changes and ESV, but maybe I'm not understanding that right. Are you suggesting some sort of dosing?

It seems like it's really hard to get good flow. My current setup with a powerhead pointed up straight up has very strong flow in some areas, but it's quite turgid in others. I'm also finding it really hard to get that prized random flow with just one pump. Alternating the power intensity helps, but the truth is it primarily pushes in one direction. I actually have an mp10 coming soon that I'm going to experiment with. I know the new tank will have mp10s, so I thought I'd play around with this one on the current tank.
If you're referring to ESV 2part - it does not supplement trace elements. I've posted about this before but it is a very common misconception. RHF, Bob Stark, and others have explained this in other threads better than I can - but basically it only replaces the traces due to the consumption of the alkalinity - which leaves excess sodium that slowly dilutes the natural balance of traces in the tank. It should not be considered the same thing as "dosing" trace elements to account for the coral consumption.

Do an ICP test to see where your traces are and various folks here can help you interpret the results. This is not typically identified as the cause for coral death or significant unhappiness (low traces that is, excess toxic trace elements are another matter) but the broad consensus is that they are important for coloration.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2021
Messages
151
Stumbled across the build when looking for threads on battlecorals, love the detail of the posts and thought processes explained. Hope the tank is doing well, Sean.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2023
Messages
134
Stumbled across the build when looking for threads on battlecorals, love the detail of the posts and thought processes explained. Hope the tank is doing well, Sean.
Thanks so much for the kind words. The journal is really for me to process what I'm trying to do. I don't expect anyone to wade through all that writing. I'm way overdue for another update, but the tank is doing great. I did switch gears from an SPS tank to a low-flow torch, ricordia, LPS tank. The lack of movement was killing me and I needed to simplify things because of a big work project I had. I do miss SPS and want to do it again sometime. True update coming soon!

PXL_20260429_171440824.MP.webp

PXL_20260427_013603706.MP.webp

PXL_20260331_190837776.MP.webp
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2021
Messages
151
Thanks so much for the kind words. The journal is really for me to process what I'm trying to do. I don't expect anyone to wade through all that writing. I'm way overdue for another update, but the tank is doing great. I did switch gears from an SPS tank to a low-flow torch, ricordia, LPS tank. The lack of movement was killing me and I needed to simplify things because of a big work project I had. I do miss SPS and want to do it again sometime. True update coming soon!

View attachment 79275
View attachment 79277
View attachment 79278
I appreciate the length and detail you gave, it reminds me of how I think about things with my tank. Well just know there's at least one other person wading through most of it haha. I've also considered a similar switch due to competing priorities.

Looking forward to the update!
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2023
Messages
134
June 12, 2026

The end of the SPS experiment

I had a really big project at work and my notes from this period are sparse. In short, I made some major changes to make maintenance easier. That included removing a lot of live rock, reducing the flow, and getting rid of my SPS.

Overall, I really enjoyed the SPS experiment and it made me feel like keeping acros was doable. I think SPS can be done at this size, but I just got impatient. That said, I do think mixing SPS and LPS is very hard in a small tank. Good flow seems possible, at least with the two MP10s (even if that seems like overkill), but it seems like you’ll never get that good turbulence like in a bigger, deeper water column. At the same time, it’s really hard to find sheltered spots for the LPS, so I feel like if you are going to do SPS in a tank this size, you have to commit.

Ultimately, the question was if I can have only one tank, is it something with a few colorful sticks or something with movement. After a full year and some change, I just wasn’t patient enough for the sticks. I’d love to try it again, but ultimately I’d rather have a torch/goni tank than sticks.

March 2026 New Era with Minimal Rockwork

I had a big work project coming up and realized there was a structural problem that I just couldn’t ignore anymore. I could not get a razor to the bottom glass without serious effort. Hair algae would grow and the dinos would then latch onto that. It was a pain to maintain.

I couldn’t put the big changes off any longer and I got rid of the large vertical rock. My hope was that by leaving one small rock, things would look more minimal – which is ultimately the kind of tank I’d like to keep. It would also be easier to maintain because I could get my hand in all the nooks and crannies finally.

Things suffered when I was one for two weeks during the winter holidays. the overall trend had swung from positive to negative. Before I left for the holidays, I felt like things had been getting steadily better for several months – basically since my last post in September. Even then, only a few corals were really thriving. Most were just existing. The dinos, though temporarily tamed, never really went away. Red cyano was starting to get comfortable in some places.

Many of my problems went away instantly after removing the big rock. Cyano totally gone. The dinos did attempt a comeback, but they just didn’t have enough hair algae to grab onto to really get big. Eventually, they gave up.

I kept a few acros to see how they did and to see if I could get them going again before parting with them. They seemed to like the extra flow, but I wasn’t until the day before I gave them away, that I noticed they were hardly getting any light. In my heart, I believe with better light and a little more time they would have been pretty happy. I gave away some to boun in a DBTC, hoping they will recover and be available to the club. That’s the dream at least.

The new layout had me thinking about the overall tank vibe from a different perspective. If I could only keep, say, five corals, what would they be? I found that a bunch of sticks wasn’t really it. I wanted at least one “movement” coral and it was hard to keep high-flow SPS and LPS happy at the same time.

Then I saw some nice torches at High Tide and it was suddenly clear that I wanted to go back to the roots of this aquarium and have a nice torch as its centerpiece–the ultimate movement coral, imho. The torches were still there went I went back, so I picked one up, turned down the flow (still kept the two MP10s), and started a new era for this thing.

PXL_20260331_190912395.MP.webp


Kessil 360WE Lights Keep Dying

My Kessil a360 WE died and I was able to replace it with an even older Kessil 360 very generously donated by club member @Galoot. I didn’t know at the time, but the replacement light did not put out nearly as much light as its predecessor. So, the combo of remounting and low PAR meant that the SPS was kinda sad looking when I gave it away.

The power supply on one of the new (old) lights died after a couple weeks. Then a few months after that, it seemed to die again, but mysteriously came back after unplugging and plugging it in a few times. That had me thinking I should just pony up the money for a newer 360x. I don’t feel like I need the extra PAR, but I wanted better reliability.

I bought a 360x on eBay, but I’ve had really bad luck there. In all my years buying used stuff on Craigslist and online, nearly every instance of getting something that doesn’t work has been reef stuff on eBay. Once it was an MP10 that had a wrecked wet side and this time it was a Kessil 360x that had a lot of burnt out LEDs and barely put out any PAR. Both times, the seller made it right without too much hassle, so I can’t complain much, but it makes me not want to buy things there anymore.

I ended up splurging on a Kessil a360xe. It’s physically a very small device and I was able to fit it in the tiny spot just underneath the bookshelf where bracket for the gooseneck is. I took the keyring off the default screw mount (not sure what to call that thing) and threaded a zip tie through the hole and then up and through the two slits in the gooseneck bracket. The screw seems solid and the zip tie is rated for 45lbs, so it’s not coming down.

My theory is that this light provides most of the heavy lifting. It’s also changed how I think about lighting in the tank. I never liked shining a light through the front piece of glass. I felt like it filtered some of the intensity and maybe some of the spectrum—although I don’t have any evidence for that. Also, there have probably been significant advances in these LED reef lights since the a360WE came out over 10 years ago.

The 360xe is such complete overkill. I run it at a peak of 5%. I turned the a80 down to 70% which gives me about 250 PAR for the torches, 100 for the sand bed and 100-150 for most of the rock. All of that seems real good to me. I’m hopeful the improved spectrum improves things somehow—either growth or color or both.

That third light got me thinking about lighting in general and reinforced my theory about the importance of being a crazy person about shadows. Not only is the lighting very even—with lights angled from the back and the front and now directly above—but I saw how important it was to light up the rear wall, at least if you have a bright white background like I do. I thought I might eliminate the light on the gooseneck and keep the rear a80 and directly above 360xe, but now I can see the important role it has in brightening the rear panel and just how much better that makes the tank look. Even if the gooseneck 360we isn’t proving much PAR, it is improving the overall look of the tank.

Bare Bottom Out, Sand In

I’m not sure what got me going on sand exactly. Previously, it seemed easier and cleaner to just razor everything every couple weeks. I felt like nearly everybody’s sand bed usually looks like crap with diatoms or cyano or whatever. My hope was that adding sand would get me out of scraping the bottom, which is harder than any of the side panels.

Kenny very graciously ended up giving me some sand from his tanks at High Tide Aquatics. I only need a few scoops to lightly cover the bottom. Unsurprisingly, that threw things out of whack for a bit. The dinos that had been suddenly beaten when I reduced the rockwork came roaring back. They didn’t dominate very long and the two or three following waves were wimpy and short-lasting.

Sand In. Phosphates Up

Tank moodiness wasn’t very surprising, but my phosophates went up suddenly and have stayed up in the following few months. They went from mostly undetectable to 0.40-0.60. Getting phosphates up has always been a struggle, so I don’t really mind. The Todd’s torch and frogspawn were grumpy for two or three weeks after adding sand but have since come back quite strongly. There are few better greens than a fast-growing, really happy torch. It’s definitely what the former SPS configuration was missing.

Nitrates Still Low. Dosing Ammonium Bicarbonate

I still can’t keep nitrates up. They were 0.12-0.17 for a while after adding sand, but then steadily dropped back to zero. I added a little bit of ESV Nitrate to boost it—as I’ve done a few times before—but I honestly don’t see any changes. I bought some ammonium bicarbonate and started dosing that with the second, now-unused dosing pump. I’m using 20ml into 500ml water at 1.3ml per day.

Kalkwasser

I’ve been dosing Kalk for a few months. I was curious about it. Many people speak mystically about its power and I wanted to see what it would do for my pH. The pH meter showed that swings from 8.5 at peak down to 7.5 at night were not uncommon.

I was surprised by two things. First, I expected Kalk to affect the pH more. I set it to dose when the lights are winding down and then at a slighter lower rate overnight. The result did change the pH, but it really only moved it from dips around 7.5 up to 7.8. The peak has also moved down to about 8.3, but that could be for other reason, IDK. So if all of that change can be attributed to Kalk, then that’s a move from 8.5 - 7.5 to 8.3 - 7.8—that’s better, I guess.

The second thing that surprised me was how much volume was required. 2-part is a little too concentrated for my tiny tank and I had been diluting it, but the amount of Kalk required to maintain the same alkalinity was a lot different. That’s going to be obvious to a lot of people reading this. It meant moving from dosing 7ml of diluted ESV 2-part to about 40ml of saturated Kalk.

I ended up changing my dosing container from a 4oz eye dropper bottle, to a 32oz Ball mason jar, and that unlocked several changes that I ended up liking a lot. The first was that I could use the relatively watery Kalkwasser to supplement the ATO. 40ml is still relatively small but it makes a difference. A jar of Kalk lasts a couple weeks, so it’s pretty low maintenance. That takes some of the pressure off the ATO, which generally has to be refilled about every 3-4 days.

I also liked the Ball jar solution because it is easy to unscrew the collar and pull the jar off the RO line. If I had to twist the entire like a normal lid, the grommet would be sticking and the lid itself doesn’t really have room to turn anyways. The collar and the jar lid basically live on the doser line. When the jar is low, I pull the jar out and slap a new one in—since I have tons of these jars. Then I can mix another batch really quickly and easily because with saturated Kalk, there’s really no need to measure things. At least as I understand it, as long as there’s some powder at the bottom, you’re fully saturated. So I rotate between two jars and the whole operation from removing the old and refilling it takes mere seconds.

I know Kalk only like this may require tinkering with trace elements down the line, but that risk seems worth it to me right now. That said, I could see myself going back to 2-part or trying All for Reef. I may have to get a third dosing pump.

PXL_20260612_180655862.webp


Scoly for a Bright Red Coral

Everything was very green heavy for a while. I wanted a very bright red to contrast with the torch would be nice. Scolys immediately came to mind, but, as far as I can tell, they’re nearly all wild harvested. If they’re mostly harvested in a sustainable way, I’m OK with that, but it’s hard to know. Like most of us, I prefer getting stuff that’s been in captivity for a while. I also personally prefer something I can frag.

I also thought about acans or zoas for my red, but ultimately ended up getting a warpaint scoly. We got off to a little bumpy start I might have hurt it with too much light (~200-150 PAR) or it was hurting already when I bought it. Some flesh retreated soon after I bought it so I could see the skeleton. I eventually put it on the sand bed in the front corner, which I worry isn’t a great spot for it. Visually, it’s nice. Hard to beat that bright red color.


PXL_20260519_234759700.MP.webp

OG Bounce Mushroom

I’ve lusted after an OG Bounce for years now. It’s hard to justify the expense, but I finally took the plunge in early June. I ended up getting one from @psidriven. It’s been really good so far. The color is insane. I’m exciting to finally have one. It never looks sad. Just bigger and better all the time.


PXL_20260612_180552655.MP.webp




PXL_20260612_180427690.MP.webp

Reef Flux Fluconazole

I think I have some Bryopsis and have had it for some time. It hasn’t been too hard to deal with, but I heard that fluc is a pretty safe way to attack it. And, it’s apparently possible to eliminate it—meaning if you don’t reintroduce it, then you won’t have it anymore. The instructions say to turn the skimmer off, but I left it full blast for a few hours. I then turned it down a little and then a lot. My theory of the tank is that the skimmer does a lot of heavy lifting and so I was really reluctant to turn it off. It’s a DC skimmer and I turned it all the way down, so it’s aerating the tank and drawing in water for surface skimming, but hardly anything is bubbling into the skimmer cup.

Eternal Enemy Bubble Algae

I used to think bubble could be defeated with manual removal, but now I’m really down on that concept. Manual removal doesn’t get much easier than this, and the bubble still finds ways to survive and come back. I want to try combining manual removal with attacking it with fluc or even riskier algaecide like Algaefix/Vibrant. I’m sick of the bubble. Unlike the Bryopsis or GHA or whaver this other stringy stuff is, the bubble doesn’t have a cycle of waxing and waning. Once is gets going, it just keeps going till it’s truly everywhere.

Looking to Add More Critters

I’m looking for suggestions on ways to add more life to this thing. Anything really. Shrimps, crabs, whatever. Anything that makes the tank feel alive. I need more life.

The fire shrimp is at least three years old now. My understanding is they live about 2-3 years, so I don’t know how much more time it has left. They are beautiful, but utterly lacking in personality—or at least mine is. I’d be willing to exchange that beauty for some personality next time.

Overall Thoughts

I feel like things are approaching another golden age. A really happy, fast-growing bright torch is really tough to beat visually and it’s a perfect center piece for this tank. The trade offs between bare bottom and sand seem worth it. Scraping the bottom every 2-4 weeks was a pain. I’d rather have Bryopsis growing through the sand and 0.40-0.60 phosphates than that. The other four panels still need to be scraped but eliminating one—and the most difficult one—feels like a legitimate upgrade.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2023
Messages
134
October 9, 2026

PXL_20261001_202058831.MP.webp


PXL_20261001_202113649.MP.webp



Another Kessil a360xe


When the a360 WE kept threatening to die, I got that a360x on Ebay that ended up not putting out any PAR. I saw that Kessil sometimes fixes lights, so I emailed them for an estimate. They ended just sending me a new 360xe in exchange for the busted 360x, even though it wasn’t under warranty and I wasn’t asking for one. I was pretty impressed with that customer service. The lawyer in me worried about the wisdom of sending new lights without much proof, but maybe Kessil thinks it’s better to get occasionally scammed than to leave its customers with busted lights for too long.

WWC Hollywood Nights Goniopora

I’ve never had a goni. They have nice movement and a lot of people seem really into them. I ended up getting a “Hollywood Nights” from WWC. They say they’ve been propagating it for a while, which piqued my interest.

It’s definitely nice. Overpriced. Seemingly hardy, so that’s worth paying for. The yellow tips look good. Good movement. Under white lights, it has that familiar purple brown color. If you already run blue and like to use the orange glasses, it is really awesome. It does not look pink except under those conditions.

It seems to be coping with living near a torch, so I’m pretty happy about that. A lot of corals can’t do that. Or maybe that Todd’s torch doesn’t have a very strong sting. Balancing coral aggression is a really important part of keeping such a small tank.


PXL_20261001_202210041.MP.webp

Scoly Dipping Treatments

I’m worried about the scoly. It was hurting a little when I got it and it’s survived but never really thrived. I wonder if the brittle stars living in its exposed skeleton are keeping it from coming back all the way. There are also a lot of bristle worms living underneath it. I want to get a scoly holder to lift it off the sand bed and try giving it periodic dips to get the pests off. I might make a separate post about this. I’d also be looking for advice about what kind of dip. I currently dip nothing and YOLO everything.

Flatworms Surged and Died Back

I think some flatworms (red planaria type) hitchhiked in on a torch or the Yuma. It’s hard to say if they were always there and I just didn’t notice. Either way, there was an explosion of flatworms. Within a matter of days they were all over the glass and soon they were on nearly every surface, including the sand.

I cooked up a plan to nuke them with Flatworm eXit and do rapid huge water changes to slow the dead flatworms from poisoning the tank. It never really seemed urgent, all the occupants were fine, and so I was slow getting around to it. After a few weeks, they kind of just died down on their own. They are still there, but there aren’t huge blooms of them like before. The whole episode was kind of weird. There’s a real tension in reef tanks between reacting decisively and not making too many sudden changes. In this case, staying the course seems like the right call. My notes for this episode are bad, but as of October, they haven’t been a problem for at least 3 or 4 months.

Fluconazole Was a Huge Success

The fluconazole (Reeflux) took a while to take effect, but it really worked well. It wiped out the Bryopsis and badly hurt the bubble algae. It’s probably one of the few things I regret not doing earlier. No side effects. All upside. It was a real turning point for this thing.

Wild Yuma Didn’t Make It

I knew I was taking a risk when I got that yuma ricordea that was wild caught. Like a lot of people in the club, I try to get aquacultured stuff. It’s both hardier and it feels morally better. It started out great. It was threatening to release its foot when I got it and within a couple weeks, it planted its foot on the plug. Over time, its bubbles decreased and it lost its color. Eventually it was a deathly gray color and just unhappy looking most of the time. Thinking it was getting too much light and maybe too much flow, I moved it to a very shady and low flow area. Two or three months later, it released its foot and floated to the back under the skimmer.

OG Bounce Update

This thing is still killing it. It’s more than doubled in size. It’s probably about 4” across when it’s really happy. I’ve never had any problems with it. It always looks happy. The color is amazing. The bubbles have a nice little movement.

It overpowers the nearby Florida Ricordea and plays well with the favia. It’s possible it handles the frogspawn sting, but it’s also possible they haven’t touched yet.

A really great coral. Hall of fame, for sure. Wish they weren’t so expensive so everyone could have one. I hope this one continues to do well.


PXL_20260921_005242744.MP.webp

Great Owl Zoas, Pink Chalice, and the War on Asterinas

I got some great owl zoas from @ on kind of a whim. They are a nice yellow and red color, which I was already looking for and they have been in the hobby for a while. The only problem was the asterina starfish found them tasty. There were multiple attacks which I was able to stop without too much damage. But then one ate an adult-sized polyp in less than an hour. I had to decide between the asterinas, which I like, and the great owls. Ultimately, I declared war on the asterinas and removed the ones I could see. After taking about 20 out, they were pretty much gone. There were a few survivors here and there and another attack, but for as long as these delicious Great Owl zoas are in there, I think I’m gonna have to abstain from asterinas.

@ also gave me a pink chalice. It’s a color that I’ve been totally lacking. It’s a really nice piece. It’s growing well but it’s not as bright as @ had it. Maybe it needs more light. I have it on the sand bed and it’s host to a big ball of bristle worms.

Too Many Bristle Worms

I have too many bristle worms. I understand they are harmless and part of the clean up crew and all that, but they are gross and there’s just way too many. I’d love to replace them with something else. When I had a bare bottom I was able to siphon out a huge percentage of them, but they came back over time. I ordered a bristle worm trap. Open to other suggests for anything that will outcompete them or prey on them.

Magnetic Back Rock Suggestions

I’m looking for suggestions for this magnetic rock on the back. Thinking maybe either fireworks polpys or some other spreading something like GSP that you wouldn’t put on a rock. Maybe some type of clove polyp or montipora or cyphastrea. I kinda miss the brightness of the setosa. Not sure how well it would grow there. Basically, I’m looking for bright—as always—and trying to take advantage of its relative isolation on the back wall.

Torch Splitting and Losing Flesh

The Todd’s Torch was killing it for a long time. It had a thin little flesh band when I got it and it’s grown a lot taller with a long band.

Suddenly, it started loosing flesh at the bottom. It looked like RTN, but the rest of the torch wasn’t really shriveled. It didn’t hide all day like my first one did for months before it finally croaked. The polyps were extended and otherwise normal looking despite the alarming and rapid tissue loss at the base. Experienced torch keepers can weigh in here, but I wonder if it’s a part of splitting or a growth technique to grow up and pull up the base behind it. I’m optimistic that all is normal. It was really hard not to take action watching it fall off considerably over a 5-day period. It’s trying to split at least three ways.

It is the centerpiece of the tank, so fingers crossed all is well. I know that torches sometimes die suddenly for seemingly no reason.

Phosphates Now Off the Chart

Phosphates were reliably between 0.40 and 0.60 in the sand era, until about August when they were suddenly too high for the Hanna checker. I asked Kenny to double check for me and it was consistent. I’m not really worried. The corals all look good. There’s no nuisance anything. I don’t have any delicate corals. I’ve heard of other tanks with eye wateringly high phosphates that are doing great.

I still do weekly water testing, but I’m kind of a water testing truther. I don’t know if it’s ever told me anything useful.

Larger Remote ATO Reservoir

I replaced the vase ATO reservoir with a much larger one from Advanced Acrylics.

In terms of maintenance, this is a huge upgrade. The vase held about a quart, which lasted 3-4 days. The new reservoir holds over 3 gallons (4”x14”x14” is technically 3.3 gallons). That turns one of my most frequent inflexible maintenance tasks into a monthly one.

This wouldn’t have been possible when my kids were smaller, because I was afraid they’d tip it over. But they are older and smarter now.

I spliced in new wiring with lever nuts and bought (overpriced) PVC tubing and put them in a split sleeve wire loom, which is a lot neater and nicer looking than the loose wires. Some amount of rat’s nest is unavoidable, but I’ve seen some real doozies on some reef tanks. The distance and head height are no problem. The pump is a little loud rattling against the sides, so I ordered one of those 3D printed holders hoping that will isolate it somewhat.

Skimmer Maintenance 3 Years Later

The skimmer slowly and then suddenly decreased its output. It didn’t seem like it was producing many bubbles. I siphoned some feather dusters and other detritus out of where the pump sits inside the skimmer, but it only helped for a little bit. In the over three years I’ve had this skimmer, I’ve never removed it for maintenance. The reason is the shelf right above the tank and the old rockwork I rested against it and blocked it in. The new, smaller rockwork made it more feasible to remove it, but it’s still a PITA. When the skimmer stopped sending bubbles up the skimmer neck and the tank was filled with microbubbles, I knew I couldn’t put it off any longer.

When I pulled it apart, the airline was visibly clogged with a rock of what looked like salt. I broke it up with my fingers and used a syringe with water to flush it out. The manual flags this as a potential issue and there is a certain satisfaction in reading the manual and then seeing the very problem it warned you about. The manual says to flush it with vinegar. It would have taken a lot of time, water, and attempts to do with a syringe, so I’m glad I opened it up and visually inspected it. I learned something about the skimmer in the process.

I also took the opportunity to try putting a coarse sponge under the skimmer to deal with the microbubbles. Tiny bubbles have been a constant problem in this tank since the beginning. I kind of resigned myself to living with them. They don’t hurt anything and the only one who cares is me. There was an old post on the reef hellsite about putting a sponge or filter floss underneath where the water comes out.

It actually worked really well. The microbubbles are way down and the tank is much clearer. It’s a really nice upgrade. The sponge may eventually become a detritus trap, but that’s a trade I’m willing to live with. Maintainable at worst. Another nice feature is that it plugged up my blood shrimp’s favorite spot to hide all day, so I actually get to see it more often. Beautiful animal but boring as hell. This one has been with me since the beginning.

Planning for Older Equipment

The heater worries me the most. In thinking of ways things can suddenly go catastrophically wrong, the heater getting stuck in the on position seems most likely. I might reluctantly get one of those inkbirds, but it’s yet more wiring rat’s nest and another control box. The heater is a scary piece of equipment because only a few things are able to wreck things like that. If it just died—like a normal piece of equipment—that seems fine, since a few days in the low 70s doesn’t seem like a big deal. Cooking the tank, on the other hand, seems bad.

I don’t know how long these cobalt neotherm heaters are supposed to last, but it’s been over three years already and they don’t make them anymore. Heaters seem like a real crapshoot and it seems like even high quality brands can fail unexpectedly. It would be nice if you could just pay money for reliability or even swap them out on a regular schedule, but it seems like even new ones sometimes fail suddenly.

My sense is the average lifespan of a nano reef tank is very short. I’m trying to plan for things that might not last well.

Overall Thoughts

One of my main goals was to reduce maintenance and make the maintenance I had easy. I’m feeling pretty good about that right now. 33% water changes take less than 5 minutes. Moving 5 gallons is not a lot of grunting and I’m usually only taking 1-2 gallons out. The skimmer needs a 3 minute scrubbing once every couple weeks. Going with sand eliminated one of the four surfaces to scrape. No nuisance algae, dinos, or cyano for many months is really huge too in terms of maintence and overall enjoyability. The big ATO reservoir has also made a huge change in the frequency of required maintenance. Buying water instead of mixing it has also been huge, since it’s one less thing to do with all its concomitant equipment and, besides, having an excuse to go to High Tide every month with my kids is just fun. I actually have enough time to maintain things, but as a puzzle, it’s been fun to try to figure out the best way to easily keep a reef tank.

My lights are definitely overkill. The dosing pumps might be too. But if I were to start this tank over again, I’d definitely still have the ATO, Tunze 9004 skimmer, and two MP10s.

I’m feeling good about growing out what’s been planted. There are two more spots to fill whenever. But otherwise I’m mostly looking to grow what I’ve invested in.
 

Attachments

  • PXL_20261001_202117042.MP.webp
    PXL_20261001_202117042.MP.webp
    128.1 KB · Views: 14
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
8,616
I am concerned them stinging each other in the near future.
My compliments to your beginning
But I will recommend growing out a single species in such a small environment.
Or at least species that inhabit different regions of the reef…fluffy and tall vs low and horizontal
Just a thought…
It’s your thang, do whatcha wanna do!
 
Top