June 12, 2026
The end of the SPS experiment
I had a really big project at work and my notes from this period are sparse. In short, I made some major changes to make maintenance easier. That included removing a lot of live rock, reducing the flow, and getting rid of my SPS.
Overall, I really enjoyed the SPS experiment and it made me feel like keeping acros was doable. I think SPS can be done at this size, but I just got impatient. That said, I do think mixing SPS and LPS is very hard in a small tank. Good flow seems possible, at least with the two MP10s (even if that seems like overkill), but it seems like you’ll never get that good turbulence like in a bigger, deeper water column. At the same time, it’s really hard to find sheltered spots for the LPS, so I feel like if you are going to do SPS in a tank this size, you have to commit.
Ultimately, the question was if I can have only one tank, is it something with a few colorful sticks or something with movement. After a full year and some change, I just wasn’t patient enough for the sticks. I’d love to try it again, but ultimately I’d rather have a torch/goni tank than sticks.
March 2026 New Era with Minimal Rockwork
I had a big work project coming up and realized there was a structural problem that I just couldn’t ignore anymore. I could not get a razor to the bottom glass without serious effort. Hair algae would grow and the dinos would then latch onto that. It was a pain to maintain.
I couldn’t put the big changes off any longer and I got rid of the large vertical rock. My hope was that by leaving one small rock, things would look more minimal – which is ultimately the kind of tank I’d like to keep. It would also be easier to maintain because I could get my hand in all the nooks and crannies finally.
Things suffered when I was one for two weeks during the winter holidays. the overall trend had swung from positive to negative. Before I left for the holidays, I felt like things had been getting steadily better for several months – basically since my last post in September. Even then, only a few corals were really thriving. Most were just existing. The dinos, though temporarily tamed, never really went away. Red cyano was starting to get comfortable in some places.
Many of my problems went away instantly after removing the big rock. Cyano totally gone. The dinos did attempt a comeback, but they just didn’t have enough hair algae to grab onto to really get big. Eventually, they gave up.
I kept a few acros to see how they did and to see if I could get them going again before parting with them. They seemed to like the extra flow, but I wasn’t until the day before I gave them away, that I noticed they were hardly getting any light. In my heart, I believe with better light and a little more time they would have been pretty happy. I gave away some to boun in a DBTC, hoping they will recover and be available to the club. That’s the dream at least.
The new layout had me thinking about the overall tank vibe from a different perspective. If I could only keep, say, five corals, what would they be? I found that a bunch of sticks wasn’t really it. I wanted at least one “movement” coral and it was hard to keep high-flow SPS and LPS happy at the same time.
Then I saw some nice torches at High Tide and it was suddenly clear that I wanted to go back to the roots of this aquarium and have a nice torch as its centerpiece–the ultimate movement coral, imho. The torches were still there went I went back, so I picked one up, turned down the flow (still kept the two MP10s), and started a new era for this thing.
Kessil 360WE Lights Keep Dying
My Kessil a360 WE died and I was able to replace it with an even older Kessil 360 very generously donated by club member
@Galoot. I didn’t know at the time, but the replacement light did not put out nearly as much light as its predecessor. So, the combo of remounting and low PAR meant that the SPS was kinda sad looking when I gave it away.
The power supply on one of the new (old) lights died after a couple weeks. Then a few months after that, it seemed to die again, but mysteriously came back after unplugging and plugging it in a few times. That had me thinking I should just pony up the money for a newer 360x. I don’t feel like I need the extra PAR, but I wanted better reliability.
I bought a 360x on eBay, but I’ve had really bad luck there. In all my years buying used stuff on Craigslist and online, nearly every instance of getting something that doesn’t work has been reef stuff on eBay. Once it was an MP10 that had a wrecked wet side and this time it was a Kessil 360x that had a lot of burnt out LEDs and barely put out any PAR. Both times, the seller made it right without too much hassle, so I can’t complain much, but it makes me not want to buy things there anymore.
I ended up splurging on a Kessil a360xe. It’s physically a very small device and I was able to fit it in the tiny spot just underneath the bookshelf where bracket for the gooseneck is. I took the keyring off the default screw mount (not sure what to call that thing) and threaded a zip tie through the hole and then up and through the two slits in the gooseneck bracket. The screw seems solid and the zip tie is rated for 45lbs, so it’s not coming down.
My theory is that this light provides most of the heavy lifting. It’s also changed how I think about lighting in the tank. I never liked shining a light through the front piece of glass. I felt like it filtered some of the intensity and maybe some of the spectrum—although I don’t have any evidence for that. Also, there have probably been significant advances in these LED reef lights since the a360WE came out over 10 years ago.
The 360xe is such complete overkill. I run it at a peak of 5%. I turned the a80 down to 70% which gives me about 250 PAR for the torches, 100 for the sand bed and 100-150 for most of the rock. All of that seems real good to me. I’m hopeful the improved spectrum improves things somehow—either growth or color or both.
That third light got me thinking about lighting in general and reinforced my theory about the importance of being a crazy person about shadows. Not only is the lighting very even—with lights angled from the back and the front and now directly above—but I saw how important it was to light up the rear wall, at least if you have a bright white background like I do. I thought I might eliminate the light on the gooseneck and keep the rear a80 and directly above 360xe, but now I can see the important role it has in brightening the rear panel and just how much better that makes the tank look. Even if the gooseneck 360we isn’t proving much PAR, it is improving the overall look of the tank.
Bare Bottom Out, Sand In
I’m not sure what got me going on sand exactly. Previously, it seemed easier and cleaner to just razor everything every couple weeks. I felt like nearly everybody’s sand bed usually looks like crap with diatoms or cyano or whatever. My hope was that adding sand would get me out of scraping the bottom, which is harder than any of the side panels.
Kenny very graciously ended up giving me some sand from his tanks at High Tide Aquatics. I only need a few scoops to lightly cover the bottom. Unsurprisingly, that threw things out of whack for a bit. The dinos that had been suddenly beaten when I reduced the rockwork came roaring back. They didn’t dominate very long and the two or three following waves were wimpy and short-lasting.
Sand In. Phosphates Up
Tank moodiness wasn’t very surprising, but my phosophates went up suddenly and have stayed up in the following few months. They went from mostly undetectable to 0.40-0.60. Getting phosphates up has always been a struggle, so I don’t really mind. The Todd’s torch and frogspawn were grumpy for two or three weeks after adding sand but have since come back quite strongly. There are few better greens than a fast-growing, really happy torch. It’s definitely what the former SPS configuration was missing.
Nitrates Still Low. Dosing Ammonium Bicarbonate
I still can’t keep nitrates up. They were 0.12-0.17 for a while after adding sand, but then steadily dropped back to zero. I added a little bit of ESV Nitrate to boost it—as I’ve done a few times before—but I honestly don’t see any changes. I bought some ammonium bicarbonate and started dosing that with the second, now-unused dosing pump. I’m using 20ml into 500ml water at 1.3ml per day.
Kalkwasser
I’ve been dosing Kalk for a few months. I was curious about it. Many people speak mystically about its power and I wanted to see what it would do for my pH. The pH meter showed that swings from 8.5 at peak down to 7.5 at night were not uncommon.
I was surprised by two things. First, I expected Kalk to affect the pH more. I set it to dose when the lights are winding down and then at a slighter lower rate overnight. The result did change the pH, but it really only moved it from dips around 7.5 up to 7.8. The peak has also moved down to about 8.3, but that could be for other reason, IDK. So if all of that change can be attributed to Kalk, then that’s a move from 8.5 - 7.5 to 8.3 - 7.8—that’s better, I guess.
The second thing that surprised me was how much volume was required. 2-part is a little too concentrated for my tiny tank and I had been diluting it, but the amount of Kalk required to maintain the same alkalinity was a lot different. That’s going to be obvious to a lot of people reading this. It meant moving from dosing 7ml of diluted ESV 2-part to about 40ml of saturated Kalk.
I ended up changing my dosing container from a 4oz eye dropper bottle, to a 32oz Ball mason jar, and that unlocked several changes that I ended up liking a lot. The first was that I could use the relatively watery Kalkwasser to supplement the ATO. 40ml is still relatively small but it makes a difference. A jar of Kalk lasts a couple weeks, so it’s pretty low maintenance. That takes some of the pressure off the ATO, which generally has to be refilled about every 3-4 days.
I also liked the Ball jar solution because it is easy to unscrew the collar and pull the jar off the RO line. If I had to twist the entire like a normal lid, the grommet would be sticking and the lid itself doesn’t really have room to turn anyways. The collar and the jar lid basically live on the doser line. When the jar is low, I pull the jar out and slap a new one in—since I have tons of these jars. Then I can mix another batch really quickly and easily because with saturated Kalk, there’s really no need to measure things. At least as I understand it, as long as there’s some powder at the bottom, you’re fully saturated. So I rotate between two jars and the whole operation from removing the old and refilling it takes mere seconds.
I know Kalk only like this may require tinkering with trace elements down the line, but that risk seems worth it to me right now. That said, I could see myself going back to 2-part or trying All for Reef. I may have to get a third dosing pump.
Scoly for a Bright Red Coral
Everything was very green heavy for a while. I wanted a very bright red to contrast with the torch would be nice. Scolys immediately came to mind, but, as far as I can tell, they’re nearly all wild harvested. If they’re mostly harvested in a sustainable way, I’m OK with that, but it’s hard to know. Like most of us, I prefer getting stuff that’s been in captivity for a while. I also personally prefer something I can frag.
I also thought about acans or zoas for my red, but ultimately ended up getting a warpaint scoly. We got off to a little bumpy start I might have hurt it with too much light (~200-150 PAR) or it was hurting already when I bought it. Some flesh retreated soon after I bought it so I could see the skeleton. I eventually put it on the sand bed in the front corner, which I worry isn’t a great spot for it. Visually, it’s nice. Hard to beat that bright red color.
OG Bounce Mushroom
I’ve lusted after an OG Bounce for years now. It’s hard to justify the expense, but I finally took the plunge in early June. I ended up getting one from
@psidriven. It’s been really good so far. The color is insane. I’m exciting to finally have one. It never looks sad. Just bigger and better all the time.
Reef Flux Fluconazole
I think I have some Bryopsis and have had it for some time. It hasn’t been too hard to deal with, but I heard that fluc is a pretty safe way to attack it. And, it’s apparently possible to eliminate it—meaning if you don’t reintroduce it, then you won’t have it anymore. The instructions say to turn the skimmer off, but I left it full blast for a few hours. I then turned it down a little and then a lot. My theory of the tank is that the skimmer does a lot of heavy lifting and so I was really reluctant to turn it off. It’s a DC skimmer and I turned it all the way down, so it’s aerating the tank and drawing in water for surface skimming, but hardly anything is bubbling into the skimmer cup.
Eternal Enemy Bubble Algae
I used to think bubble could be defeated with manual removal, but now I’m really down on that concept. Manual removal doesn’t get much easier than this, and the bubble still finds ways to survive and come back. I want to try combining manual removal with attacking it with fluc or even riskier algaecide like Algaefix/Vibrant. I’m sick of the bubble. Unlike the Bryopsis or GHA or whaver this other stringy stuff is, the bubble doesn’t have a cycle of waxing and waning. Once is gets going, it just keeps going till it’s truly everywhere.
Looking to Add More Critters
I’m looking for suggestions on ways to add more life to this thing. Anything really. Shrimps, crabs, whatever. Anything that makes the tank feel alive. I need more life.
The fire shrimp is at least three years old now. My understanding is they live about 2-3 years, so I don’t know how much more time it has left. They are beautiful, but utterly lacking in personality—or at least mine is. I’d be willing to exchange that beauty for some personality next time.
Overall Thoughts
I feel like things are approaching another golden age. A really happy, fast-growing bright torch is really tough to beat visually and it’s a perfect center piece for this tank. The trade offs between bare bottom and sand seem worth it. Scraping the bottom every 2-4 weeks was a pain. I’d rather have Bryopsis growing through the sand and 0.40-0.60 phosphates than that. The other four panels still need to be scraped but eliminating one—and the most difficult one—feels like a legitimate upgrade.