Welcome to BAR - the Bay Area's premier saltwater hobbyists hub!

Bone cutter recommendations

Guest
Joined
Jul 17, 2009
Messages
1,938
The bone cutters I purchased from BRS are crap. I cleaned and wiped the cutters dry after each use and the screw that holds them together seems to be rusting. It's so hard to open and close now. They are stainless steel but I think I should have gotten surgical steel instead.

I see good reviews for the Boston Aquafarms cutters but does anybody have any recommendations for others? I'd prefer to buy local rather than buying online.
 
G

GreshamH

Guest
All of them will rust, I've bought one from pretty much every supplier (or was given one).

I like the BAF anodized ones and TAAM's Rio one.
 
Guest
Joined
May 22, 2006
Messages
1,383
Try Titanium. I'm tempted to buy scalpel and other tools, but expensive.
 
Guest
Joined
Jul 17, 2009
Messages
1,938
Haha Jim you're funny. :D

Gresham, the BAF ones you recommend are the same as the surgical steel ones and they still rust?

Do your Rio's rust? Anywhere that sells locally?
 
Guest
Joined
Aug 18, 2006
Messages
9,047
sfboarders said:
Haha Jim you're funny. :D

Gresham, the BAF ones you recommend are the same as the surgical steel ones and they still rust?

Do your Rio's rust? Anywhere that sells locally?


The Rios rust as well, they all do, you know what saltwater does, it corrodes EVERYTHING, some things just take longer than others :D

I'm still looking for cutters that can chop though 3/4" Acro branches...
 
Guest
Joined
May 22, 2006
Messages
1,383
tuberider said:
sfboarders said:
Haha Jim you're funny. :D

Gresham, the BAF ones you recommend are the same as the surgical steel ones and they still rust?

Do your Rio's rust? Anywhere that sells locally?


The Rios rust as well, they all do, you know what saltwater does, it corrodes EVERYTHING, some things just take longer than others :D

I'm still looking for cutters that can chop though 3/4" Acro branches...

this? http://cgi.ebay.com/Colibri-Titanium-GOLD-Cigar-Guilotine-Cutter-70-GIFT-/280516942950?cmd=ViewItem&pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item41501cdc66#ht_3190wt_1139
 
Guest
Joined
May 22, 2006
Messages
1,383
or this: http://cgi.ebay.com/Apple-Trading-Company-7-Diagonal-Cutter-Titanium-/350352458311?cmd=ViewItem&pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item5192a24247#ht_721wt_913
 
Guest
Joined
Apr 25, 2004
Messages
2,249
tuberider said:
sfboarders said:
Haha Jim you're funny. :D

Gresham, the BAF ones you recommend are the same as the surgical steel ones and they still rust?

Do your Rio's rust? Anywhere that sells locally?


The Rios rust as well, they all do, you know what saltwater does, it corrodes EVERYTHING, some things just take longer than others :D

I'm still looking for cutters that can chop though 3/4" Acro branches...
I think you're looking for tree trimmers!
 
G

GreshamH

Guest
bookfish said:
tuberider said:
sfboarders said:
Haha Jim you're funny. :D

Gresham, the BAF ones you recommend are the same as the surgical steel ones and they still rust?

Do your Rio's rust? Anywhere that sells locally?


The Rios rust as well, they all do, you know what saltwater does, it corrodes EVERYTHING, some things just take longer than others :D

I'm still looking for cutters that can chop though 3/4" Acro branches...
I think you're looking for tree trimmers!

I use PVC shears for this :)
 
Guest
Joined
Feb 5, 2009
Messages
512
I have also encounter the stainless steel bone cutters rusting on me. The bone cutters eventually gets stuck. I just dunked the cutters into half vinegar and half water for 15 mins, scrubbed it with a tooth brush, and open and closed it a million times. Now it's working as it was brand new.
 
Guest
Joined
Apr 25, 2004
Messages
2,249
GreshamH said:
bookfish said:
tuberider said:
sfboarders said:
Haha Jim you're funny. :D

Gresham, the BAF ones you recommend are the same as the surgical steel ones and they still rust?

Do your Rio's rust? Anywhere that sells locally?


The Rios rust as well, they all do, you know what saltwater does, it corrodes EVERYTHING, some things just take longer than others :D

I'm still looking for cutters that can chop though 3/4" Acro branches...
I think you're looking for tree trimmers!

I use PVC shears for this :)
That's a really good idea I never thought of!
 
G

GreshamH

Guest
Wait, I thought i've seen you use them like this before Jim? I get cheap ones at the Dollar store or harbor Freight. I then wash the bejesus out of them to remove any traces of oil from production. I use a little Dr Bronners on them to help remove the oil.
 
Guest
Joined
Aug 18, 2006
Messages
9,047
GreshamH said:
bookfish said:
tuberider said:
sfboarders said:
Haha Jim you're funny. :D

Gresham, the BAF ones you recommend are the same as the surgical steel ones and they still rust?

Do your Rio's rust? Anywhere that sells locally?


The Rios rust as well, they all do, you know what saltwater does, it corrodes EVERYTHING, some things just take longer than others :D

I'm still looking for cutters that can chop though 3/4" Acro branches...
I think you're looking for tree trimmers!

I use PVC shears for this :)


Awesome! I knew there was an answer somewhere out there!!!!
 
Guest
Joined
Aug 29, 2007
Messages
9,048
I wish they made the cutters out of 316L SS :(
 
Guest
Joined
Aug 29, 2009
Messages
2,445
Bone Cutter used to be my C.B. handle. 'Ol Bone Cutta on this Duck Pluckin' end..........
Just kidding, of course. I used to talk to a guy called "Meat Cutter" though...........

Fresh water rinse thoroughly every time makes a big difference. Mine get stained with epoxy finger prints as I'm usually using them in the middle of a mounting proceedures.
 
Guest
Joined
Jul 17, 2009
Messages
1,938
bee505 said:
I have also encounter the stainless steel bone cutters rusting on me. The bone cutters eventually gets stuck. I just dunked the cutters into half vinegar and half water for 15 mins, scrubbed it with a tooth brush, and open and closed it a million times. Now it's working as it was brand new.

Just tried out your suggestion Bennett and works much better.

I'm gonna see if my mom can get me some bone cutters from work (she works in the surgery dept. :))
 
Guest
Joined
Aug 29, 2009
Messages
2,445
zepplock said:
Try Titanium. I'm tempted to buy scalpel and other tools, but expensive.
The only time I use a scalpel is when I'm fragging zoa colonies on a disc, I saw through the disc and scalpel through the zoas inbetween the heads. Although I bought a surgical scalpel, the disposies work just fine.
 
Guest
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
24
I've had a pair of Boston Aqua Farms cutters for a few months now, and have been able to keep the rust under control. The screw that acts as the hinge shows some slight signs of rust, but it still moves freely and easily (i.e. gravity can open it). I think that the most important thing to do is to soak the cutters in hot fresh water after using them, and then just dry them thoroughly. Eventually though, I think that the saltwater will prevail as it does with everything.

What I haven't seen yet is the rusting from under the finish like you see with some of the polished silver colored ones.

So all in all, I'm fairly happy with these cutters.
 
G

GreshamH

Guest
The black ones are anodized... I don't think it acts like a chrome does, or a paint does, as far as lifting off ;)
 
Top