Welcome to BAR - the Bay Area's premier saltwater hobbyists hub!

Torch dropped bunch of polyps - can this reattach?

Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2024
Messages
2,592
Maybe try something similar to what I did here?

Although, if the torch came off because that polyp itself was stung to bits, it might not survive the stinging.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2025
Messages
629
Whenever fw dipping, we often ignore temperature and pH difference.. this is applicable more for the fish fw dips, but may be applicable for some sensitive corals as well.. I would keep the same temperature and use baking soda to bring the ph of the RODI water to similar levels before dipping, even if it’s only meant to be done for few seconds.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2024
Messages
2,592
Whenever fw dipping, we often ignore temperature and pH difference.. this is applicable more for the fish fw dips, but may be applicable for some sensitive corals as well.. I would keep the same temperature and use baking soda to bring the ph of the RODI water to similar levels before dipping, even if it’s only meant to be done for few seconds.
I definitely pH adjust freshwater dips for animals such as corals and clams. I thought this was standard practice?
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,464
Maybe try something similar to what I did here?

Although, if the torch came off because that polyp itself was stung to bits, it might not survive the stinging.

Thank you. This melted away in the nano tank within 24 hours.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2023
Messages
3,464
I’ve dipped, shaken,brushed football sized rocks covered in nems, zoas and leathers fairly hardy stuff in temp matching distilled or rodi water to chicken to attempt tap water lol.. But definitely use a square bin alot easier with bigger rocks. Black bins hard to see anything that falls off so I use the clear or different colored ones. Or white buckets with small rocks. After quick dip and shake in temp matching rodi I place in saltwater bin for a few minutes then repeat another fast dip in shake again in rodi then back in saltwater bin shaking more. but I have pumps in both bins water is fairly turbulent. Also did this once a week for several weeks before I treated with Flatworm exit.. Logic was to knock down populations ahead of treatment so would lessen the toxicity when they all died off at once. Not sure how other corals handle freshwater dip.. Funny at the older coral farmers market was common to see people in the restrooms rinsing off their frags in the sinks which left some serious slime residues

This sounds like a massive effort. And would still require flatworm exit which I really do not want to use as this might be the death sentence for at least my spotted mandarin.

I also do not want any chemical stuff in my tank if unless it is live and death.

Levamisole Hydrochloride does not sound too bad, but who knows what else will die as a result.

I strongly feel that adding this trades one problem for another, which is why I generally like the dipping idea, and I have dipped some rocks before, but not at that large scale.

Maybe I need to add a proven fish (100% certified flatworm eater). The melanurus wrasse and spotted mandarin were both added to fight flatworms, and maybe they keep the population at bay, or just enjoy all the other meals served daily.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2023
Messages
445
This sounds like a massive effort. And would still require flatworm exit which I really do not want to use as this might be the death sentence for at least my spotted mandarin.

I also do not want any chemical stuff in my tank if unless it is live and death.

Levamisole Hydrochloride does not sound too bad, but who knows what else will die as a result.

I strongly feel that adding this trades one problem for another, which is why I generally like the dipping idea, and I have dipped some rocks before, but not at that large scale.

Maybe I need to add a proven fish (100% certified flatworm eater). The melanurus wrasse and spotted mandarin were both added to fight flatworms, and maybe they keep the population at bay, or just enjoy all the other meals served daily.
I have two Mandarins in my 110g display + 30g sump. I recently dosed Interceptor at 4x concentration for 5 weeks straight. This kills a lot more invertebrates and pods than Flatworm exit. I never feed my Mandarins anything directly. They did just fine. In a large enough system the Mandarins are basically impossible to kill since it is near impossible to wipe out your copepod population. If I stopped feeding the tank for six months most fish would die but the Mandarins would live! They are like cockroaches once established.
 
Last edited:
Supporting Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
8,497
Flatworms….
I dipped in FW and broke up this huge colony
It was about 22 inches in diameter
 

Attachments

  • 77386746928__051D3D62-0912-4BE1-B5BC-743C46729028.webp
    77386746928__051D3D62-0912-4BE1-B5BC-743C46729028.webp
    252.1 KB · Views: 57
  • 77386752351__763C417D-CC2D-42BC-AE99-5DB024B0DCA6.webp
    77386752351__763C417D-CC2D-42BC-AE99-5DB024B0DCA6.webp
    127.7 KB · Views: 59
Top