Welcome to BAR - the Bay Area's premier saltwater hobbyists hub!

Co2 refill

Guest
Joined
Feb 27, 2019
Messages
3,000
Damn all this talk of CO2 making me start to think calcium reactor considering I'm dosing about 2.5 gallons of kalkwasser a day, although that's a major investment in money maybe I'll just break out some buckets and do 2 part dosing.
.
Do it..do it.
CArx are awesome :))
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2016
Messages
16,461
Damn all this talk of CO2 making me start to think calcium reactor considering I'm dosing about 2.5 gallons of kalkwasser a day, although that's a major investment in money maybe I'll just break out some buckets and do 2 part dosing.
.

2.5g of kalk a day? Damn that’s like pouring 2 jugs of milk into your tank daily.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2016
Messages
16,461
How are you not getting any mold and condensation problem yet?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2005
Messages
17,384
Do it..do it.
CArx are awesome :))
Should I get DaStaCo or the Deltec one? :) Seriously it's fun spending someone else's money :D

But yeah, cheapest thing is the CO2 tank, slap a regulator on that $$, then a feed pump $$$, oh yeah don't forget the calcium reactor itself $$$, I don't have an Apex either so need to have some controller as a failsafe $$$.
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2005
Messages
17,384
How are you not getting any mold and condensation problem yet?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
*shrug* I dunno, house leaks air like a sieve? So constantly pulling air in and out? I honestly don't know, but I haven't seen mold yet anywhere near the tank.
 
Guest
Joined
Feb 27, 2019
Messages
3,000
Should I get DaStaCo or the Deltec one? :) Seriously it's fun spending someone else's money :D

But yeah, cheapest thing is the CO2 tank, slap a regulator on that $$, then a feed pump $$$, oh yeah don't forget the calcium reactor itself $$$, I don't have an Apex either so need to have some controller as a failsafe $$$.
Lol. Right?!. Ever seen this site


Ofcourse carx is not a must and high initial investment. I think there are some cheaper options and good out there.
You do not need an apex, a good carx is safer than you would think...
you can pair the reactor with a stand alone kh tester like khg or khd..thatd another $450 to $550 thu..
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2005
Messages
17,384
Ofcourse carx is not a must and high initial investment. I think there are some cheaper options and good out there.
You do not need an apex, a good carx is safer than you would think...
you can pair the reactor with a stand alone kh tester like khg or khd..thatd another $450 to $550 thu..
Yeah I know it doesn't HAVE to be a high initial investment but being as my lagoon is in the 300g range I can't exactly go with a tiny setup otherwise I'll be investing more down the road, so unless I find a dirt cheap setup it will be a bit of a high initial invest (and that's even without going to the fancy Deltec Twin Tech setup :D).

And I know you don't need an Apex, but some sort of pH controller would probably be recommended as a fail safe in case the tank pH gets too low which is where I'm thinking. I don't think a KHG would be terribly effective as a safety net though, absolutely great for making sure things are dialed in but being as it doesn't continuously test your kH there'd be too big of a window where disaster can happen.
 
Guest
Joined
Feb 27, 2019
Messages
3,000
Yeah I know it doesn't HAVE to be a high initial investment but being as my lagoon is in the 300g range I can't exactly go with a tiny setup otherwise I'll be investing more down the road, so unless I find a dirt cheap setup it will be a bit of a high initial invest (and that's even without going to the fancy Deltec Twin Tech setup :D).

And I know you don't need an Apex, but some sort of pH controller would probably be recommended as a fail safe in case the tank pH gets too low which is where I'm thinking. I don't think a KHG would be terribly effective as a safety net though, absolutely great for making sure things are dialed in but being as it doesn't continuously test your kH there'd be too big of a window where disaster can happen.
Curious to know what disasters can CArx can cause? Especially in a less than 2 hour window?
I actually believe kh tester will be very effective. I cannot think of a disastear scenario that the kh tester would not catch it on time and shut off the reactor. Granted you need some sort of controller with to shut off with it, except in case of khg since there is a khg CArx module that do the control for you without a controller.
 
Last edited:
Supporting Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2005
Messages
17,384
Well the biggest what if is if the CO2 uncontrollably floods the reactor, granted it may be far fetched but I'm guessing CO2 could drop the reactor quite a bit. Now that I think of it though you'd also need to have a dosing mishap as well uncontrollably dumping reactor juice into the tank. So yeah, it's pretty much not going to happen... but it could! :D
 
Guest
Joined
Feb 27, 2019
Messages
3,000
Well the biggest what if is if the CO2 uncontrollably floods the reactor, granted it may be far fetched but I'm guessing CO2 could drop the reactor quite a bit. Now that I think of it though you'd also need to have a dosing mishap as well uncontrollably dumping reactor juice into the tank. So yeah, it's pretty much not going to happen... but it could! :D
Yup, while these are corner cases, but it does show the importance of having a way to control either the co2 solenoid or the reactor main power.
Both can be done through a controller or stand alone CArx modules controllers
Thanks for sharing.
 

EBJ

Guest
Joined
Feb 6, 2016
Messages
411
Yeah I know it doesn't HAVE to be a high initial investment but being as my lagoon is in the 300g range I can't exactly go with a tiny setup otherwise I'll be investing more down the road, so unless I find a dirt cheap setup it will be a bit of a high initial invest (and that's even without going to the fancy Deltec Twin Tech setup :D).

And I know you don't need an Apex, but some sort of pH controller would probably be recommended as a fail safe in case the tank pH gets too low which is where I'm thinking. I don't think a KHG would be terribly effective as a safety net though, absolutely great for making sure things are dialed in but being as it doesn't continuously test your kH there'd be too big of a window where disaster can happen.
Just use 2 part
 
Supporting Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2008
Messages
1,415
You can also get CO2 refills at Carbonic Services in SJ for about $22. It's usually about a 10 minute wait. So it's really quick. They can also re-certify tanks too.
 
Top