Kessil

Who has the largest collection of chalice corals private or retail?

That actually sounds like a really interesting experiment. I wonder how it will work once it eventually converges in the middle? Especially these ones with different color growth rims
 
I’d probably keep the center for re-grow out, and try to get some of the different colored frags from the edges to fuse again. I’ve had some success getting red/blue cuts to fuse but they have to be fresh cuts, placed edge to edge and helps if the skeleton is aligned so the growth ridges point in the same direction. Once the growth rim comes in sometimes the same chalice will grow over itself rather than fuse again. This would be trying to get three frags to fuse... if I can grow other types of rainbow chalices out to where I have more expendable pieces it would be interesting to try to see if they would also fuse in some conditions.
 
Chalices have always been my reef kryptonite, while I absolutely can keep them alive they just never seem to grow in any reasonable time period. Had one that looked great, color was great, 2 years later it barely grew larger than the frag plug it was on.
 
@sfsuphysics I’m curious what kind of PAR/flow did you have your chalices in? I’ve noticed they can slow down in too much as well as too little light or if you don’t feed them. I’m not sure but seems like slower water movement helps them capture their own food.
 
@Coral reefer I searched a few online vendors and the most I saw was 35 at WWC and they’re may have been duplicates. Most vendors I searched had 20-30 different colors listed

But that’s not the best way to tell cause they tend to list what’s available not what’s in their whole collection.

Are you looking to expand your collection, or to chat with another collector and discuss your experiences with the different chalices. I’m not sure what causes the color change, but the orange chalice I got from you how has a bunch of yellow streaks
4BF2C10F-1DE3-4DCA-B7FC-5E89A526E2C9.jpeg
 
@sfsuphysics I’m curious what kind of PAR/flow did you have your chalices in? I’ve noticed they can slow down in too much as well as too little light or if you don’t feed them. I’m not sure but seems like slower water movement helps them capture their own food.
Honestly couldn't say what the PAR was. I've had them in numerous tanks under different lighting, metal halides, t5s, LEDs. But I don't think the light was ever too extreme to be honest, I mean I mostly would grow SPS, but still always had a good range of brightness.

Personally I think they know I'm not exactly a wealthy person, probably sees me as more of a cup coral type of guy *rimshot*
 
Mike, your collection is crazy..does all your chalices identified or you have some that are not named or know in the market? I just cannot imagine what a 100 chalice looks like ha.
 
Many have been ordered from asd, so named, but not legit names. They just make stuff up.
some from wwc
Many from AC. No names.
A few from Neptune. No names.
A smattering from members here. Mostly not named stuff.
 

Attachments

  • E99784DC-08FB-4D68-AF2B-F2B42F280B41.jpeg
    E99784DC-08FB-4D68-AF2B-F2B42F280B41.jpeg
    160.1 KB · Views: 146
  • FE2609EE-D715-4601-A90B-38792C1A5DB9.jpeg
    FE2609EE-D715-4601-A90B-38792C1A5DB9.jpeg
    131.4 KB · Views: 149
  • 24FD7137-BDFE-4634-813A-057F31C43A35.jpeg
    24FD7137-BDFE-4634-813A-057F31C43A35.jpeg
    65.8 KB · Views: 158
  • F28885F0-EE1C-4C2F-900B-5098E40B2CDA.jpeg
    F28885F0-EE1C-4C2F-900B-5098E40B2CDA.jpeg
    68.7 KB · Views: 152
  • E4D1FFBA-77C3-49EB-9C2F-FB5712C3A699.jpeg
    E4D1FFBA-77C3-49EB-9C2F-FB5712C3A699.jpeg
    54.9 KB · Views: 149
  • 6DD6113C-2270-44CC-AC4B-5E70DB96320B.jpeg
    6DD6113C-2270-44CC-AC4B-5E70DB96320B.jpeg
    62.5 KB · Views: 154
  • 65AF77AB-55B5-48A2-9C00-4F79942F979B.jpeg
    65AF77AB-55B5-48A2-9C00-4F79942F979B.jpeg
    82.5 KB · Views: 150
  • 1C1CC3E8-84AE-489D-9204-824FD1D8E168.jpeg
    1C1CC3E8-84AE-489D-9204-824FD1D8E168.jpeg
    83.5 KB · Views: 142
Last edited:
Few more
 

Attachments

  • 0E519CBA-2339-4B91-AE19-9F8C65699DE4.jpeg
    0E519CBA-2339-4B91-AE19-9F8C65699DE4.jpeg
    76.9 KB · Views: 152
  • 55F0BAF8-FE69-4E6E-80F7-592DE90EC993.jpeg
    55F0BAF8-FE69-4E6E-80F7-592DE90EC993.jpeg
    57.5 KB · Views: 155
  • 22DD8BA2-DBDB-4534-9666-73C519A325B6.jpeg
    22DD8BA2-DBDB-4534-9666-73C519A325B6.jpeg
    55.5 KB · Views: 161
  • F50EE696-A268-4DA8-937D-0912982F63BE.jpeg
    F50EE696-A268-4DA8-937D-0912982F63BE.jpeg
    45.4 KB · Views: 169
  • 0B59A472-6A45-4337-BE36-7EE58D741BAA.jpeg
    0B59A472-6A45-4337-BE36-7EE58D741BAA.jpeg
    100.6 KB · Views: 149
  • 9219226A-4344-4185-BEDB-5AC42E521A7A.jpeg
    9219226A-4344-4185-BEDB-5AC42E521A7A.jpeg
    80.8 KB · Views: 152

Attachments

  • 9FBD417A-1CBD-4B38-B7CD-E86300B326EE.jpeg
    9FBD417A-1CBD-4B38-B7CD-E86300B326EE.jpeg
    72.5 KB · Views: 154
  • 3ED0FEEE-C5BB-4E7F-B612-062161830E46.jpeg
    3ED0FEEE-C5BB-4E7F-B612-062161830E46.jpeg
    82.5 KB · Views: 158
  • FCF1DA99-4620-46F1-9796-1ED08727D5B4.jpeg
    FCF1DA99-4620-46F1-9796-1ED08727D5B4.jpeg
    73.5 KB · Views: 150
  • 9BCD8DFD-E215-4E6A-85F9-62FBD9140D61.jpeg
    9BCD8DFD-E215-4E6A-85F9-62FBD9140D61.jpeg
    66.5 KB · Views: 166
  • E883787A-8058-4B9C-B96B-A78CE2D0CCD2.jpeg
    E883787A-8058-4B9C-B96B-A78CE2D0CCD2.jpeg
    83.3 KB · Views: 165
  • 80163A85-B3A4-4F14-BCB9-700F53F35599.jpeg
    80163A85-B3A4-4F14-BCB9-700F53F35599.jpeg
    57.8 KB · Views: 159
  • E3E7E37C-3B90-41B7-857E-CB96A5EC88F1.jpeg
    E3E7E37C-3B90-41B7-857E-CB96A5EC88F1.jpeg
    53.9 KB · Views: 154
  • F888ADCD-FD80-4BA4-BCEA-C966C6EC39B3.jpeg
    F888ADCD-FD80-4BA4-BCEA-C966C6EC39B3.jpeg
    65.2 KB · Views: 154
Enough for now?
 

Attachments

  • 9E04B61E-83BF-458A-8D6C-44115D0E1F61.jpeg
    9E04B61E-83BF-458A-8D6C-44115D0E1F61.jpeg
    51.5 KB · Views: 149
  • 24187954-542E-4E6B-9B20-2835CF1194E4.jpeg
    24187954-542E-4E6B-9B20-2835CF1194E4.jpeg
    56.3 KB · Views: 161
  • 2636D011-03AE-4A83-8D79-FD73A1FB7B34.jpeg
    2636D011-03AE-4A83-8D79-FD73A1FB7B34.jpeg
    52.2 KB · Views: 156
  • AB6CD2CB-C06C-461C-943D-ED7989F9D4EA.jpeg
    AB6CD2CB-C06C-461C-943D-ED7989F9D4EA.jpeg
    65.8 KB · Views: 151
  • D6D98292-005D-4F72-893C-BC5ADF12D27F.jpeg
    D6D98292-005D-4F72-893C-BC5ADF12D27F.jpeg
    69.8 KB · Views: 144
  • 613CBC94-7BB8-4D41-B190-CCFD08003D3F.jpeg
    613CBC94-7BB8-4D41-B190-CCFD08003D3F.jpeg
    69.8 KB · Views: 144
  • C347C8AE-4687-45E7-8B30-3CEF871E5BF7.jpeg
    C347C8AE-4687-45E7-8B30-3CEF871E5BF7.jpeg
    62.4 KB · Views: 146
  • 455D444B-CC26-4F64-BDC9-06170AC18CB5.jpeg
    455D444B-CC26-4F64-BDC9-06170AC18CB5.jpeg
    49.2 KB · Views: 161
Back
Top