got ethical husbandry?

Knock off / Clone MP10- MP-40

nanoguy said:
Looks like it uses suction cups to hold the dry/wet side to the glass :confused:.
Click to expand...
Looks like maybe it's both - it does specify glass thickness, which says magnet to me?

If it's both it's a pretty awesome solution to when one of the sides just falls off the tank after removing the other, which used to drive me absolutely crazy when I had an MP40.
 
Yeah it does look like that. If you listen to Doung from Boston reefers. He doesn’t like mp’s because of the magnets. He says it’s a failure point in the design. That over time. It grinds the impeller into the body.
 
Screenshot_20240924_162836_Chrome.jpg


here you go
 
I really like the no cords aspect of the vortechs, and would be interested to hear how these work out. The suction cup aspect seems neat if it helps prevent a knock from destroying the dry side as it falls to the ground because you forgot to use a sticky cable holder. I feel a bit weird about a knock off taking the idea they first developed, but there also hasn't really been innovation on these vortech pumps since the first time I remember seeing them back near 2000.

I wish there was a way for them to support a form factor with a pivot though. I've started using some other types in my frag tank, and as long as I get the cord threaded against a hidden area or black wall, I find being able to point it at things valuable.

It'd probably be very inefficient, but I wonder how much current can be passed through a glass panel. Wall electric => magnetic dry side => internal magnet => electric inside => final pump.

Effectively use the two magnets as a power transfer so you don't have to run a cord through. Alternatively I wonder how long until Red Sea starts selling a tank with integrated powerheads and no visible cords. Seems like you could do a lot with a bulkhead to run a cord through attached to a PVC riser behind the tank, without having to go all the way to a closed loop.

Sorry for the minor thread hijack.
 
I'm pretty excited if these patents are expiring. It means an open opportunity for people to take existing ideas and take them in all kinds of directions, allowing more visions to come true than just one company's, and hopefully means that prices will fall + more options.

I wish you could angle them too, but I agree with you about the efficiency problem - the tech is not there. With Apple magsafe, even with all the orientation magnets, with the two coils being millimeters apart, etc, it's 15 watts for all regular and pro phones up until the 16 series, which still is just 25w. For reference, an MP40 is 38 watts.

Imagine that, but now both pieces are made to be separated by sometimes nearly an inch and not perfectly aligned. You can always crank up the power, but it creates lots of heat.

I wonder if there's an adjustable 3d-printable flow director you can slap on the wetside, maybe comboed with a nem guard? I attached an image of a inflexible one, but I know there's lots of cool 3D printing tricks now that allow for some degree of mobility (at least until the coralline gets to it, by which hopefully you would get them dialed in?) Until someone makes one I hope this might fit your use case.

For now I stick with my Jebao lol :p $44 pump ftw
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot 2024-09-25 at 12.42.25 AM.png
    Screenshot 2024-09-25 at 12.42.25 AM.png
    536.2 KB · Views: 45
What makes you guys think there is any current going through the glass? It looks to me on how it functions is the same as a vortech. Except they put suction cups for extra support, which is not actually a bad idea.
 
tribbitt said:
I wonder if there's an adjustable 3d-printable flow director you can slap on the wetside
Click to expand...
They have them:

www.4daquatics.com

Vortech Movable Nozzles | 4D Aquatics

Expand directional control of your Ecotech Vortech pump up to 18 degrees in all directions. These 3D printed components snap perfectly onto your Ecotech Vortech wetside. The rubber clips make removing for cleaning simple. * Includes both wide and narrow flow nozzles* Made with reef-safe...
www.4daquatics.com www.4daquatics.com
 
iani said:
What makes you guys think there is any current going through the glass? It looks to me on how it functions is the same as a vortech. Except they put suction cups for extra support, which is not actually a bad idea.
Click to expand...
We don’t. He was wondering if we could angle the flow by wirelessly powering a directable wet side.

My thought is that it would likely be inefficient and that using a flow director is probably the play, at least until tech gets better
 
MichaelB said:
I'm always skeptical of those sites, lol i picture getting the item and it being half an inch big, or the size of ceiling fan.
Click to expand...
I use aliexpress somewhat often. it’s the amazon of china. So far everything has been as advertised and arrived within a week.

I’ve recieved the wrong model of something though. Recently got a cable, arrived with the wrong connector. I noticed after a week, and a free refund was issued the same hour I reported it.

You do have to be wary of actual scams but if you’ve been shopping anywhere online you will probably encounter some scams, just brace yourself to see more of them lol
 
tribbitt said:
We don’t. He was wondering if we could angle the flow by wirelessly powering a directable wet side.

My thought is that it would likely be inefficient and that using a flow director is probably the play, at least until tech gets better
Click to expand...
Ic, but the thing with this is why even bother with this, just add more pumps at this price. I've never had the need to direct the flow on my vortechs.
 
Man has it already been 20 years since the first Vortech pump? Damn I guess it has, I remember having the "gen 1" pumps, where you could see the actual metal magnet since it only had some clear coat over it or something, and that absolutely rusted away and bulged in no time, they were nice enough to replace them though with the now epoxy coated ones. Also the controller was a "dumb" controller (it did have some feedback circuitry though) but it was little more than a knob that controlled speed, and I really missed having that since the direction of "smart" and also wireless to talk to each other significantly raised the prices on them. I think I still got pieces of those floating around downstairs too, because of course I do which reefer throws away anything?

edit: I notice the one with the "US plug" isn't available, I wonder if it's not quite kosher to sell in the US yet? Or did they all get snatched up at that price point or something?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top